Viewing page 9 of 9 pages. Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Providing independent power to the onboard audio via a molex connector did
not result in any increase in power consumption. We noticed a moderate decrease
in static and background noise when the extra power connector was on, but nothing to write home
about. The "DTS Surround Sensation" was not tested as we do not believe
it is a worthwhile feature in this type of product. Most enthusiasts capable
and willing of building a true HTPC will have a real multi-channel sound system,
so synthesizing a multi-speaker setup with stereo speakers would be pointless.
Emulated surround sound is probably more effective with headphones but not many
HTPC users use them. The gold-plated RCA connectors are convenient for stereo
speakers since you do not require an adapter, but the plating itself has little
value outside of preventing oxidation.
The Asus M4A78-HTPC/RC is a very capable motherboard in its own right, i.e.
if we ignore the remote and audio extras. It has plenty of features including
HDMI, S/PDIF, and eSATA, and its heart, the tried and true HD 3200 IGP, is fully
capable of high definition video playback. With SpeedFan, one can fully control three
fans connected to the board independently, or if you prefer the set-it-and-forget-it
option, the board's automatic fan control system works well too. When paired
with a low TDP processor, it is one of the more energy efficient boards in its
class, both when idle and stressed. It does exhibit high power consumption when
paired with an AM3 chip, but that seems to be a universal problem with all AM2+
motherboards. The BIOS is very restrictive and lacks the ability to undervolt,
so those who like to tinker with their systems to get the lowest power consumption
possible will have to look elsewhere.
With a solid base, Asus added features to cater to the Home Theater crowd.
The included IR remote is simple and intuitive, but the software it is paired
with lacks both polish and functionality. The current version doesn't hold a
candle to Media Center, though that could change if Asus continues working
on it. If the current version is the best they can do, it might as well have
been shipped the board with a regular MCE remote. You can use the bundled remote
with Media Center, though there are a few buttons that will only work
with Home Theater Gate.
The additional audio functionality is of limited use, in our view. Powering the board's audio
independently does reduce some static and noise but it falls short of being
a compelling must-have, must-try feature. "DTS Surround Sensation"
has limited value for a board of this type it is probably better used in
a typical desktop environment with stereo speakers or headphones rather in the
living room with a HTPC. The gold-plated RCA connectors may give the board a
level of cachet but true audiophiles will recognize it as a gimmick.
To summarize, the M4A78-HTPC/RC certainly can be a good base for a home theater
PC, but it is not necessarily our top choice. The core hardware is excellent,
but the extras that differentiate it have marginal value, in our opinion.
If the audio features came at no extra
cost, and the remote was made for use with MCE rather than Home Theater Gate, it would appeal fine.
As it stands, we can pick out any 780G board with the appropriate feature-set and
an MCE remote for functionality just as good as the M4A78-HTPC/RC package Asus is offering. The board will probably not be released in North America, so there is no official price for US/Canada. However, an online search came up with a price of 7,100 Rupees in India and 6,300 Rupees without the remote. That translates currently to ~US$150 and ~US$134, not exactly bargains in North America where mATX 780G board rarely crack $100. IT goods are often priced higher elsewhere, however, so do take our comments about value with caution.
* Low power consumption
* Independent control of up to 3 fans
* Remote works well
* Questionable audio features
* Remote software lacking in capability
* Restrictive BIOS; does not allow undervolting
Our thanks to ASUSTeK
for the motherboard sample.
* * *
Articles of Related Interest
Zotac GeForce 9300-ITX WiFi: Good
Things Come in Small Packages
Asus M4A78T-E AM3 motherboard
MSI KA760GM: 780G Minus the HD
790GX Showdown: Gigabyte vs. MSI
Zotac GeForce 8200-ITX WiFi: A Compact
Asus P5N7A-VM: Geforce 9300
* * *
Discuss this article in the
|Help support this site, buy from one of our affiliate retailers!|