Re: SPCR Quiet Certified Gaming PC by AVADirect Custom Compu
Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2012 3:08 pm
Reading the AnandTech again, it's not that bad. I think the reviewer should work on the tone of the review though...
Discussions about Silent Computing
https://www.silentpcreview.com/forums/
https://www.silentpcreview.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=64615
The whole thing starts off on a bit of a slant, and this line did not help my impression of the article as a case of review-envy. I'm sure the reviewer meant to say "just is not possible for us", but indeed worded it poorly. Also, I realise the standards are not exactly high in this field, but the sniping? That was hilarious.rpsgc wrote:This line just... grinds my gears.
No, just because you aren't able to, doesn't mean it's not possible.True to form, the AVADirect Quiet Gaming System is, indeed, quiet. I can't verify the certification by SPCR; most sound meters don't read below 30dB, so testing to see if those figures are accurate just isn't possible.
Ditto. Sniping is not going have the field progress, and if you are a reviewer, you should articulate and argue any points you would like to make.kellym2 wrote:I wish the AnandTech reviewer would have expanded more on the SPCR certification issue - what his problems and views were. He kind of dances around it. I'm not saying they couldn't be constructive but he comes off as somewhat passive/aggressive.
Wow I have to agree there. That's pretty pathetic. If you want to actually review a system for it's quietness you might want to pony up for a sound meter that reads below 30dB.rpsgc wrote:This line just... grinds my gears.No, just because you aren't able to, doesn't mean it's not possible.True to form, the AVADirect Quiet Gaming System is, indeed, quiet. I can't verify the certification by SPCR; most sound meters don't read below 30dB, so testing to see if those figures are accurate just isn't possible.
Just one more thing to add - it would be interesting to know the ambient sound level by his own computer. I know he didn't actually test anything so maybe he didn't even put the computers in the same place. My friend has his computer next to a fish tank and the computer is so quiet you can't even hear it!!!! lol Seriously though, ambient noise level is very subjective for a human (easy to block out) but not for a sound meter.rpsgc wrote: That and saying it isn't really quiet because his own computer sounds quieter... oh, did I miss the part where he actually measured it? Oh, what's that? He didn't? He's simply stating opinion as facts? Nice.What, no video card? Yeah, totally fair comparison.at the time a 4GHz Intel Core i7-990X cooled with a CoolerMaster Hyper 212+ and a pair of Scythe low speed fans, inside a SilverStone FT02
Furthermore I'd really love to know how is it that his CPU (a six-core beast @ 4GHz) idles at just 24C with a simple Hyper 212+ yet his computer is sooooo much quieter than the AVADirect. Oh, the magic of merda taurorum
It's Anandtech, what did I expect?
Good to know. I read Anandtech quite a bit for CPU news stuff.Enzo_FX wrote:Dustin's reviews are sorely lacking over at Anandtech IMO. He often complains about trivial matters, and leaves a lot to be desired in terms of looking at a lot of details.