Page 1 of 8

SPCR Designed Computer Systems

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 2:43 pm
by MikeC
SPCR Designed Computer Systems -- - Designed by Mike Chin of SPCR for very low noise, assembled and sold by experienced, professional system integrators in US & Canada.

I like!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 3:20 pm
by plympton
These are almost identical to the 2 systems I recently built, sans some of the tweaks, so I suppose I did something right! :-)

Sounds like a good partnership.

How did you get the Zalman cooler to fit - is the AM2 socket essentially an Opteron socket? I like the Zalman in my Desktop box, and thought they weren't making their older coolers work for AM2.

EDIT: I found the adaptors on their site. Now the question is whether I want a Zalman or an XP-90.. decisions decisions....

-Dan

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 3:38 pm
by rpsgc
Awesome! I wish you all the best of luck :)

Re: I like!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 4:09 pm
by MikeC
plympton wrote:These are almost identical to the 2 systems I recently built, sans some of the tweaks, so I suppose I did something right! :-)

Sounds like a good partnership.

How did you get the Zalman cooler to fit - is the AM2 socket essentially an Opteron socket? I like the Zalman in my Desktop box, and thought they weren't making their older coolers work for AM2.

EDIT: I found the adaptors on their site. Now the question is whether I want a Zalman or an XP-90.. decisions decisions....

-Dan
Sharp eyes... ;) they came up with their own adapters; just a couple of machined aluminum blocks with the right screw taps. We're looking at substituting the 7000 with a Thermalright SI-128, just exploring fit/orientation issues right now.

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 4:27 pm
by merlin
I was surprised to see the good old Zalman 7000 series still in action myself. Great articles and choices as always, I'll definitely refer people who don't mind paying for prebuilt quietness.

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 4:50 pm
by Erssa
I was just recently playing, with the idea of starting a small business to build silent systems with couple of my friends. I really think there's starting to be a market for this sort of things.

That model One seems really nice and I'm sure it will find and audience among those, who want absolutely silent PC without a hassle and don't mind paying alot for it. Personally, I think they are a bit too pricy, when in the barest form (without display) it costs 400$ more then a similarly specced 17" imac. Or when a 20" iMac is priced similarly to a pc with the same specs and without display.

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 5:40 pm
by andyb
I only read the 1st page, will read the rest tomorrow, I did look at all of the pics though and I was impressed.

I hope that SPCR keeps their feet firmly on the ground, the same ground that SPCR started on. Making computers quieter is what SPCR is all about, so long as this partnership is all about funding more reviews, more detail, more information, and of course paying the people who do the work then I applaud the SPCR EPCN partnership.

On to the more possitive side of things, those systems look quite fantastic, and the partnership deal is an obvious choise from both parties, and I am happy that it has taken this long for SPCR to make a deal with another company for the sake of revenue. This proves in my mind that SPCR has refused an awful lot of other choices over the years, and have stuck to their guns until a wholesomely worthwhile choice of partnership such as this one reared its beautiful head.

Congratulations SPCR.


Andy

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 6:21 pm
by wwenze
unless you're truly obsessed about noise and live in a soundproof bunker in the middle of the woods
I'd like to point out that, the woods is a very noisy place at night with all the animals and wind.

[serious mode]

Ever thought about... pre-tweaked systems? Like the A64 comes @ 1.2V with the option of lowering it to 1.1V, or less than that hook or crook,
Or the Nexus is temperature controlled.

It's easy to do but there would be people who don't realize it could and should be done. Trees get saved.

[/serious mode]

Is there like a big warning like "take out the bubble wrap before turning on your computer for the first time" somewhere for those who believe opening the casing results in excessive dose of radioactivity and therefore cancer?

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 6:42 pm
by NeilBlanchard
Hello,
wwenze wrote:Is there like a big warning like "take out the bubble wrap before turning on your computer for the first time" somewhere for those who believe opening the casing results in excessive dose of radioactivity and therefore cancer?
My suggestion is that EPCN should pack the AC power cord inside the bubble wrap, to make very sure that nobody powers these machines up before removing the said bubble wrap... :o

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 7:22 pm
by qviri
I was thinking the same thing actually.

They'd be dead silent, though. </bad pun>

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 7:28 pm
by MikeC
A sheet taped to the front panel of each system warns boldly not to turn the power on until the antistatic bubble wrap is removed from inside the case. This is standard for all ECPN systems.

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 7:47 pm
by wpb
Very nice systems. Great choice for the mid-tower case. I am very happy with my Solo.

I'm all thumbs when it comes to building anything from scratch. Any thoughts about selling the PSU duct separately since EPCN is going to be "mass" producing them?

Bill

Intel quad-core?

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 9:21 pm
by dcuccia
Hey Mike,

Great ideas! Three questions/requests for Model One Point One:

I haven't seen any SPCR reporting of a quiet QX6700-based system yet...think you could you get said SPC w/in your noise spec? I understand the issues, but I'm in the market for a quiet workstation (hopefully no longer an oxymoron) at work. I'm planning to build it myself, but would seriously consider something pre-built w/ support for a bit more money and less time/effort on my part.

Also (but obviously related), how about adding the new Corsair PSUs as an upgrade option? The power/heat ecosystem is a delicate one, but I'd consider the option for more headroom to be a significant value-added to the product offering. Besides the powering of quad core cpus, I ask because:

I really want the ability to upgrade to a dx10 card (for GPGPU purposes), but only when a passively cooled version (or DIY mod) is available. What's the hope that I this would be possible w/ a Model One?

(Maybe what I'm asking for is a "Model Zero" P180 quad-core w/ a 8800gts/x made as quiet as possible.)

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 9:26 pm
by nightmorph
Heck yes! The Solo system is very similar to the one I built, though with fewer fans and higher temps than my system. Still, it looks very well done.

I'm especially surprised and pleased by the prices listed at EPCN; they're quite reasonable. There's nowhere near the extreme price gouging practiced by most system integrators -- the listed components come in very close to the individual prices.

I think the thing that made me happiest was the possibility of buying without and operating system whatsoever, thus saving a nice bundle of cash. Second happiest was the fact that Linux was an option (and a much cheaper one than Windows, of course). :)

Good work, SPCR + EPCN. I'm very impressed with the offerings and the options available for each, and by the prices. What a pity I just built my own workstation -- though I did build it according to SPCR ideals. :)

Re: Intel quad-core?

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 9:29 pm
by MikeC
dcuccia wrote:(Maybe what I'm asking for is a "Model Zero" P180 quad-core w/ a 8800gts/x made as quiet as possible.)
Yeah, that's what it sounds like. A whole 'nuther model. Probably needs a P190.

Re: SPCR Designed Computer Systems

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 10:06 pm
by plympton
MikeC wrote:When the system is being used, the single biggest source of apparent noise is the WD hard drive, which causes a slight low frequency hum when the system is placed on resonant surfaces such as a hollow table top. This noise is very low in level, however, and dissipates quickly with a bit of distance. When you are seated 6~8 feet away, as in a typical TV room, the noise is extremely subtle, and not possible to hear with any music, TV program or movie sound track on.

A bit of seek noise is also audible from close up (within 3 feet) when the hard drive is writing or reading. Again, when the system is in use, this noise is below the level of entertainment sounds from the speakers.
I had the exact same problem with my 500 GB - it just drove me NUTS! (I don't use standby yet, as I haven't found it reliable under Windows Media Center Edition). Something about the NSK 2400 and that drive - the constant tick-tick-tick of the seeks while recording live-tv drove me nuts when just sitting in the TV room. I'm a freak, but popping my 320 GB WD drive in there solved the problem. Done. Was a few degrees cooler, too.

Under operation, it was a-ok, though.

-Dan

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 10:32 pm
by autoboy
Sharp eyes... they came up with their own adapters; just a couple of machined aluminum blocks with the right screw taps. We're looking at substituting the 7000 with a Thermalright SI-128, just exploring fit/orientation issues right now.
How about the arctic cooling alpine64? It is so damn cheap and seems to cool as effectively as the Zalman 7000 at low speed. I'm not sure if it can handle the hotter chips though.

Those are very nice systems. They will be on my list for friends and family. I'm getting tired of building them all the time. How bout a nice mATX system or shoebox system next? It is really hard to find a quiet shoebox PC.

I'm really suprised that you decided to duct the Solo. It seems like a large added expense for a small gain. It is all hand built and taped together. I guess that is what the buyers are paying for though, a real SPCR worthy computer without all the work.

Overall, very well done and a brilliant move to help fund SPCR. I hope the volume is good and prompts you to build more great systems in the future.

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 10:37 pm
by MikeC
autoboy wrote:I'm really surprised that you decided to duct the Solo. It seems like a large added expense for a small gain. It is all hand built and taped together. I guess that is what the buyers are paying for though, a real SPCR worthy computer without all the work.

Overall, very well done and a brilliant move to help fund SPCR. I hope the volume is good and prompts you to build more great systems in the future.
Actually, once a cutting template has been created for the duct, it's not difficult or time consuming to make. Just print it off on a large sheet of paper, which gets used as a tracer onto the construction paper EPCN chose to use. It has a significant benefit with the system under load in warm weather -- the PSU fan doesn't ramp up, so the noise quality/level stays unchanged, which is a key feature (imo) of a truly quiet, unobtrusive system.

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 10:58 pm
by HammerSandwich
Is the "Eleven" named as an homage to KLH?

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 11:11 pm
by picture_perfect
just wondering how ducting the neo affected the case temps (i can see why it was ducted because the neo in my p150 really ramps up under load)

Re: Intel quad-core?

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 11:37 pm
by dcuccia
MikeC wrote:
dcuccia wrote:(Maybe what I'm asking for is a "Model Zero" P180 quad-core w/ a 8800gts/x made as quiet as possible.)
Yeah, that's what it sounds like. A whole 'nuther model. Probably needs a P190.
Really? I'm currently running:

p180 (w/ 1 nexus 120mm case fan)
seasonic m12 700w
E6400@3ghz (arctic silver; cnps9500 w/ nexus 120mm mod)
eVga 8800gtx
4gb ram
2x750gb hdd raid0

...and everybody seems happy as a clam, and fairly quiet too (could use some AcoustiPack-ing). I just don't want to spend days building these at work. I'm about to hire a number of people and would jump on SPC workstations designed by Mike Chin.

Have you tested the noise level of a QX6700 in the Model One? It's cost is nearly equivalent to your current X6800 upgrade price, so I could just buy one and tack it on...be nice not to lose the support, though.

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 2:16 am
by roadie
MikeC wrote:
autoboy wrote:I'm really surprised that you decided to duct the Solo. It seems like a large added expense for a small gain. It is all hand built and taped together. I guess that is what the buyers are paying for though, a real SPCR worthy computer without all the work.
Actually, once a cutting template has been created for the duct, it's not difficult or time consuming to make. Just print it off on a large sheet of paper, which gets used as a tracer onto the construction paper EPCN chose to use. It has a significant benefit with the system under load in warm weather -- the PSU fan doesn't ramp up, so the noise quality/level stays unchanged, which is a key feature (imo) of a truly quiet, unobtrusive system.
Great article and business decision. I am planning to move my components to a system extremely similar to the Model One and had decided to duct my NeoHE. If there was any chance of purchasing the duct and the grill/filter for the 5.25" bay, then I would be all over it.

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 3:00 am
by jaganath
When the system is being used, the single biggest source of apparent noise is the WD hard drive, which causes a slight low frequency hum when the system is placed on resonant surfaces such as a hollow table top.
Wasn't there any way of decoupling this drive, like say with adhesive foam pads?

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 3:23 am
by Tzupy
@MikeC: IMO a fanned SI-128 wouldn't work well in the NSK2400, I have it (in P150) and it's quite tall. An XP-120 should work better.
If you want to use it fanless, you'd better fully duct it somehow to the back fan, because the fins are just 1.55 mm apart.
It seems to me that there is a niche market for low-profile passive heatsinks, like a SI-128 with larger fins but wider spaced.

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 4:34 am
by Bluefront
My take on Model One....Nice looking system and probably as quiet as possible, since you are using a conventionally configured case.

But.....It runs much too hot for my liking, both the CPU and the HD, the running temp of which I did not see. I would expect the HD to be running around 40C or slightly higher with a 21C ambient. And I wonder about all the other temps in such a low-airflow setup. I would ship it with a front intake fan installed for sure, and I would substitute a Scythe mid-speed S-Flex for the Nexus. In higher ambient temps, which are to be expected for most people in the summer, I would worry about that stock cooling ability.

And.....it could be quieter if the airflow configuration was different. I realize you must use readily available cases for this project, but because of this, you have all the intakes up front.....not the quietest case setup. I would at least eliminate the front PSU duct, and design the PSU to use an intake from somewhere less audible. And I have never been completely satisfied with the main intake from behind the front bezel.....despite numerous attempts with many cases. They are always too loud, no matter the configuration.

What I'm suggesting is a different case, with non-conventional airflow, probably designed from scratch. This Model One will be just fine for most people......and to improve on it will require a redesign, maybe a new model, and probably not a commercially smart decision.

Good luck with this new direction for SPCR....

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 6:13 am
by wussboy
I too think it's a good decision. SPCR has developed a bit of "brand power" having become the true authority in silent PCs. I don't believe anything is silent until I read it on SPCR. Marketing systems with the SPCR branding is an excellent way to profit from this.

A word of warning: Because these systems are being sold on SPCR's name, there is a real danger of the power of that name being eroded. If these computers have issues that have nothing to do with their noise levels, it will still reflect badly on SPCR, reducing the brand power. Just something to be vigilant about.

Cheers!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 6:24 am
by MikeC
wussboy wrote:I too think it's a good decision. SPCR has developed a bit of "brand power" having become the true authority in silent PCs. I don't believe anything is silent until I read it on SPCR. Marketing systems with the SPCR branding is an excellent way to profit from this.

A word of warning: Because these systems are being sold on SPCR's name, there is a real danger of the power of that name being eroded. If these computers have issues that have nothing to do with their noise levels, it will still reflect badly on SPCR, reducing the brand power. Just something to be vigilant about.

Cheers!
Thanks for the support... and the warning. What you mention is a reality that's faced by partnerships everywhere. All the more reason to go with a system integrator with experience in the field. At this time, there's no other US company with as much experience in quiet PC components and building/selling/supporting quiet PCs as EndPCNoise.

Re: Intel quad-core?

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 6:44 am
by MikeC
MikeC wrote:
dcuccia wrote:(Maybe what I'm asking for is a "Model Zero" P180 quad-core w/ a 8800gts/x made as quiet as possible.)
Yeah, that's what it sounds like. A whole 'nuther model. Probably needs a P190.
BTW, there will be other models for other applications.

Re: Intel quad-core?

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 7:38 am
by rpsgc
MikeC wrote:
MikeC wrote:
dcuccia wrote:(Maybe what I'm asking for is a "Model Zero" P180 quad-core w/ a 8800gts/x made as quiet as possible.)
Yeah, that's what it sounds like. A whole 'nuther model. Probably needs a P190.
BTW, there will be other models for other applications.
Ooooh.... goody! Can't wait to see them! :D

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 8:03 am
by Palindroman
It's great to see all that knowledge becoming available for a larger audience. My only objection is that the systems consume a lot of watts at idle (68 watts and 98 watts respectively). Excellent performance-per-watt though.
wwenze wrote:
Ever thought about... pre-tweaked systems? Like the A64 comes @ 1.2V with the option of lowering it to 1.1V, or less than that hook or crook,
Or the Nexus is temperature controlled.

It's easy to do but there would be people who don't realize it could and should be done. Trees get saved.
What are the pros and cons of pre-tweaking these systems?