HDD Elastic Suspension... Show your pics!
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
I might as well post my HDD suspension here as well:
Believe me, those SP1614Cs are absolutely silent! They are pretty quiet when hooked up too.
The frame is made out of 1/2-inch MDF, the supports are 1/8-inch bungee cord (nylon covered elastic) as loose as I could make it and still hold securely.
The next time I open up my machine, I will flip the bottom drive upside down so its hot side gets better airflow. As it stands, the bottom drive is running about 5C hotter than the top, even though it is only really used for nightly backups and is otherwise idle. The front grill has been removed since this picture was taken.
The suspension does a nice job with these drives that otherwise vibrate a fair bit. I cannot hear the drives seek at all outside of the case.
Believe me, those SP1614Cs are absolutely silent! They are pretty quiet when hooked up too.
The frame is made out of 1/2-inch MDF, the supports are 1/8-inch bungee cord (nylon covered elastic) as loose as I could make it and still hold securely.
The next time I open up my machine, I will flip the bottom drive upside down so its hot side gets better airflow. As it stands, the bottom drive is running about 5C hotter than the top, even though it is only really used for nightly backups and is otherwise idle. The front grill has been removed since this picture was taken.
The suspension does a nice job with these drives that otherwise vibrate a fair bit. I cannot hear the drives seek at all outside of the case.
Compusa hard drive heatsinks with rubber pads relocated to the bottom of drives sitting on child's play mat. Bluefront is right those heatsinks smell horrid.
Last edited by york on Mon May 02, 2005 7:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 968
- Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 7:13 pm
- Location: Bristol, UK
- Contact:
It's my suspension, since a few hours. Hard work, I don't think it get so much time to buid this. Based on EndoSteel's project and some elastic suspension. Now I know that success depend on good project and even better tools
Last edited by Stefan on Sun May 08, 2005 11:58 pm, edited 2 times in total.
l can't remember whether l've posted my pics before so appologies if you've seen them before. The first picture was my attempt at HD suspension (yes l know they're rubber bands ) but l've now changed to the 2nd method where the HD is resting on sponge.
l'm still using the same heatsink but, as you can see, l've added some holes in an effort to help air circulation. l don't know whether it's made much difference but it looks pretty.
The 80mm intake fan has since been replaced with an Akasa 120mm item that's running at around 750rpm.
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y113/s ... CF0004.jpg
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y113/s ... CF0001.jpg
l'm still using the same heatsink but, as you can see, l've added some holes in an effort to help air circulation. l don't know whether it's made much difference but it looks pretty.
The 80mm intake fan has since been replaced with an Akasa 120mm item that's running at around 750rpm.
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y113/s ... CF0004.jpg
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y113/s ... CF0001.jpg
Very ingenious!Stefan wrote:
It's my suspension, since a few hours. Hard work, I don't think it get so much time to buid this. Based on EndoSteel's project and some elastic suspension. Now I know that success depend on good project and even better tools
I like the way you did it: very clean and doesn't block airflow at all.
-
- Friend of SPCR
- Posts: 889
- Joined: Sun Dec 05, 2004 11:34 pm
- Location: Finland -- Folding For SPCR
Hi,
I managed to get hold of some GelMec silicone sheet. I cut some small pieces out of it and placed four of them between the HDD and the Sonata HDD cage/bay. I then secured it with some elastic band, that pushes the HDD to the silicone pieces.
It seems to be working similarly to suspension with my Western Digital (AAM enabled), the HDD vibrates, but I cannot feel any vibration transmitting to the Sonata's HDD bay.
I managed to get hold of some GelMec silicone sheet. I cut some small pieces out of it and placed four of them between the HDD and the Sonata HDD cage/bay. I then secured it with some elastic band, that pushes the HDD to the silicone pieces.
It seems to be working similarly to suspension with my Western Digital (AAM enabled), the HDD vibrates, but I cannot feel any vibration transmitting to the Sonata's HDD bay.
i've done so many wildly different suspension jobs but i didn't take pictures of most of them.. here's a big one from a while ago, 6 spots. when you have multiple drives the noise builds up, this machine is workhorse not allowed in the same room as me. it's a mishmash of old pieces, i bolted a huge AT drive bay into the bones of an ATX case
-
- Posts: 347
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 12:57 am
EDIT:Working picture now...
Last edited by Techno Pride on Sun Mar 11, 2007 2:27 am, edited 2 times in total.
hey josephclemente, i am going to rig up a Stretch Magic much like yours. Its one of the best looking ive found for my LianLi (with a window). Looks and quiet...very hard !!!josephclemente wrote:
That is actually my system.
I have since created a Stretch Magic suspension using a one-piece 3.5" to 5 1/4" drive adapter. Now I can remove the drive without messing with the suspension.
I was wondering if you could post pics of your new system for us all to copy... =)
-
- Posts: 968
- Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 7:13 pm
- Location: Bristol, UK
- Contact:
I replaced the original rubber grommets with Sorbothane:
Requires sorbothane, scissors / round pipe i.d. 12mm (depending on if you want octagonal or round grommets ), round pipe o.d. 5-6mm, longer M3 screws depending on thickness of sorbothane. The screws are tight enough that it squishes slightly.
Touching the screws I can feel the vibration, but none is transmitted to the tray. And I don't have to worry about tension or turning the case up on end
Requires sorbothane, scissors / round pipe i.d. 12mm (depending on if you want octagonal or round grommets ), round pipe o.d. 5-6mm, longer M3 screws depending on thickness of sorbothane. The screws are tight enough that it squishes slightly.
Touching the screws I can feel the vibration, but none is transmitted to the tray. And I don't have to worry about tension or turning the case up on end
you guys, i hope you realise that by turning a HDD upside down, you prolly will break it in 6 months.
They are disigned to be standing (kabels down), on the side (kabels on the lft or right) or normal (circuits down), but upside down and other strange angels put the Drive suspension (motor etc) in serious train as they are not designed that way.
I have a couple drives breaking cuz some bright head on DELL placed the drives upside down in the chassy, just so it looked better.
They are disigned to be standing (kabels down), on the side (kabels on the lft or right) or normal (circuits down), but upside down and other strange angels put the Drive suspension (motor etc) in serious train as they are not designed that way.
I have a couple drives breaking cuz some bright head on DELL placed the drives upside down in the chassy, just so it looked better.
Welcome to SPCR, jmkhenka!jmkhenka wrote:you guys, i hope you realise that by turning a HDD upside down, you prolly will break it in 6 months.
They are disigned to be standing (kabels down), on the side (kabels on the lft or right) or normal (circuits down), but upside down and other strange angels put the Drive suspension (motor etc) in serious train as they are not designed that way.
I have a couple drives breaking cuz some bright head on DELL placed the drives upside down in the chassy, just so it looked better.
This issue has been discussed at length, and resolved, I believe. Hard drive manufacturers actually do specify upside-down mounting as one correct way to install a harddrive, as well as vertical mounting in any orientation. There was some confusion as to whether mounting at an angle could be harmful, but I think the final consensus was that that could not possibly be harmful, either. See the full (lengthy, and at points quite technical) discussion here.
Drive suspension:
I really wanted to suspend my hard disk but it is enclosed in a cooledrive 3 so it took me a lot of effort to find
the best way to do it. So I figured out that a PSU is a little bit wider than a 5 ¼ so y used the case of an old one.
I had to mod the case to make room for the drive and a 120 mm fan, I cut the hard drive mounting and leaved
just enough of it to let me install a 3 ½ card reader unit, then I put some foam in the case to let rest the PSU case.
Here is the drive on its place.
I really wanted to suspend my hard disk but it is enclosed in a cooledrive 3 so it took me a lot of effort to find
the best way to do it. So I figured out that a PSU is a little bit wider than a 5 ¼ so y used the case of an old one.
I had to mod the case to make room for the drive and a 120 mm fan, I cut the hard drive mounting and leaved
just enough of it to let me install a 3 ½ card reader unit, then I put some foam in the case to let rest the PSU case.
Here is the drive on its place.
Last edited by agus_c_o on Thu Nov 10, 2005 10:26 am, edited 5 times in total.
-
- Posts: 20
- Joined: Tue Feb 08, 2005 12:01 am
- Location: Wroclaw, Poland
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
I'm going to mod my sonata and 3700BQE, and a suspension mod for my 4 HDs
is one of the things I'm going to do.
But what to choose.
I found on this forum 3 ideas..
1) Ralphs polyurethane ultrasoft adhesive mod (sorbothane)
2) Techno Pride's cheap elastic suspension
3) Fluxu8 elastic suspension
First I have no idea where to get the sorbothane over here (belgium).
I searched with google.be but I don't really know what to search
for, I tried 'polyurethaan zelfklevend' but only got a factory without shop..
I guess my googling ain't that great.
So the elastic suspensions are a solution, but I noticed (on the pics above)
that some suspended HDs are blocking the holes in the drive tray, and so blocking the airflow completely. Am I right or wrong in this conclusion?
Maybe adding extra holes in the cage can be an option?
Some help would be great.
is one of the things I'm going to do.
But what to choose.
I found on this forum 3 ideas..
1) Ralphs polyurethane ultrasoft adhesive mod (sorbothane)
2) Techno Pride's cheap elastic suspension
3) Fluxu8 elastic suspension
First I have no idea where to get the sorbothane over here (belgium).
I searched with google.be but I don't really know what to search
for, I tried 'polyurethaan zelfklevend' but only got a factory without shop..
I guess my googling ain't that great.
So the elastic suspensions are a solution, but I noticed (on the pics above)
that some suspended HDs are blocking the holes in the drive tray, and so blocking the airflow completely. Am I right or wrong in this conclusion?
Maybe adding extra holes in the cage can be an option?
Some help would be great.
They look pretty bodgy - but the bungee cord works well... Some of those little gold goloured clips with the nails removed and replaced with screws does the trick =)
http://img393.imageshack.us/my.php?image=hdd4zl.jpg
http://img393.imageshack.us/my.php?image=hdd4zl.jpg
Case top (with optical drives removed):
Case bottom:
The box is pretty much inaudiable, just a <14db fan at the back running at 15% and a <14db psu fan running at around 40%, ca't be heard from 12" away (apart from when the hdd's are busy, then you hear a very light clicking)
They've been running like this for well over a year now with no problems
Case bottom:
The box is pretty much inaudiable, just a <14db fan at the back running at 15% and a <14db psu fan running at around 40%, ca't be heard from 12" away (apart from when the hdd's are busy, then you hear a very light clicking)
They've been running like this for well over a year now with no problems
-
- Posts: 424
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 9:08 pm
- Location: Somewhere over the rainbow....
sry for the quality, my old LEGO cam
similar to stretch magic, but it's....(drumroll) glow in the dark string
was lying around and slighty stretchy so what the heck
still can hear seeks, but not as bad as before *shudder*
yes i'm new, but not a total noob
EDIT-sometime i put my old P4 heatsink on it to cool, since currently i have no exhaust fan, (if u look closely on the left, my good ol' legos holding a stock 120mm fan at 5v cooling my once noisy ati9800. I can switch back to 12v for gaming curtousy of mike's DDPT switch)