Thank goodness I didn't fan-swap yet. I'm gonna sell my S12II and buy a VX if I can get the price 1:1.

Your S12 II 430W and the VX series use the same fan model, a medium-speed Adda AD1212MB-A71GL. What makes you think a VX would be quieter?

I think you should go ahead with exchanging the PSU, as I'm interested in a direct comparison between the two.

Same fan, so what? I didn't say I was expecting it to be quieter. I'm curious to see how a Corsair handles, and my S12II has hardly been the dream unit so far: mediocre fan combined with HDD boot troubles makes me want to swap right now. If I can get the same performance and reliability for less, I'll take it. If it's quieter, all the better, but I'm not betting on it; even with a better controller the fan has its characteristic rumble.

VX availability is poor right now, so this'll have to happen some time in the future.

Hello,

According to the JonnyGuru review, the VX450 uses the low speed Adda.

Its a medium speed.

So the HX actually use a HIGH speed fan?!

Maybe Corsair can tame the medium one too then, here's hoping!

PS. I would've swapped for a 380W in hopes of getting more reliable boots, but currently that model's not available through my sources.

Hello,

Right -- the VX uses a lower speed fan: vs the HX fan: . So it is very likely that the VX is quieter than the HX models.

Yeah, as long as the noise character is kept in check somehow. It's not so much the volume as it is the roughness that chafes with the S12II's fan.

In case you guys didn't notice, I've hijacked this thread and turned it into the discussion for SPCR's VX450W review.

Very nice review as always.

It it interesting the way that the vx450 ramps up much sharper than the others. Does anyone else think that the airflow baffle thing limits its use as a heat extractor? It seems that the baffle will help move more air over the heatsinks but at the cost of air flow rate, thus hurting it in the high loads in the SPCR test rig?

great review (and timely). Mike, any idea why Corsair didn't apply for 80Plus certification?

As far as it being non modular: modular is cool, but honestly who doesnt have excess space on either side of their PSU that has no other meaning in life other than to stuff unwanted PSU cables? Modular cables is just a marketing gimmek so they can charge more money.

That said, the fact that it isnt modular, to me anyhow, seems to sort of defeat the entire purpose. Why not just buy an S12? About the only thing i can see that stands it apart is its warrenty. 5years with 24/7 support is outstanding.

I like that they used some high quality components, some over rated by quite a bit above the average.

I'm still waiting to see a 300-400w PSU with an 80mm fan w/ modular cables from corsair. This to me would seem to be the "sweet spot" for silencing enthusiasts.

Also im glad to see SPCR getting back to what it does best. This is to date the first true SPCR hardware review in about 2 1/2 months. I dont count the LCD display as a review.

Factual error in the review: on the 5th page in the noise comparison table Seasonic S12 Energy + should have 26dBA noise rating at 300W, not 36.

Sheesh, enough already! Surely, everyone in these forums has already heard your opin many times!


Thanks, JJR, corrected.

Thanks for the review. I always look forward to them. The Pics and data in a SPCR review are always worth waiting for.

Typo on page 4: Low VAC Test: Corsair HX620W @ 351W Output

I liked the comparison table , would have been nice to see the Earthwatts 430 in the table as so many people seem to be smitten with it. I haven't caught the bug but I've been at least reconsidering it.

I might just buy a new PSU this winter or next spring instead of bothering with the fan swap on my old S12.

dhanson865 --

thanks for the comments and the typo snipe, which has been corrected. Data for the Earthwatts 430 is now in that comparison table btw.

On page 5 of the review your graph plot for the Seasonic S12-430w looks a bit odd.

Shouldn't it be like the data in the table above it?

Model_____ 90W - 150W - 200W - 250W - 300W - 400W - 450W
S12-430___ 20 - 22 - 25 - 29 - 32 - 37 - 37

You're right, it's missing the last 37C / 450W data point.

We have applied, it is pending. It will certainly be certified as it meets all the requirements as far as our internal tests can show so far. Our intent is to produce a wide-range of products that are best-in-the-field for quality, and part of our requirements is high efficiency.

For those wondering why it's not modular, simply price point. With the HX520W being <$100 at some online stores and modular, and the added cost of modular would mean that the price difference between the VX450W and the HX520W would be nearly nothing.

We wanted to launch a basic, single-GPU, non-modular PSU that was highly efficient and very quiet, and that's what the VX450W is. The VX550W is similar but for those who want a slightly higher-wattage product for low-end SLI compatibility, but still don't want to pay the difference for modular.

Ideally, the price delta between a modular and non-modular product would be $10-15 or so, retail, provided the internals are identical. That being said, we also upgrade the internal components to 105C rated caps in order to extend the MTBF and guarantee better operation at its rated 50C temps.

But fear not, we have not forsaken modular products.

We have higher-wattage products in the pipeline that are both modular and fixed cable. While you might wonder why, we've found that the market is large enough that not everyone wants the modular cables and yet everyone wants a power supply they can trust.

Our goal is to be the #1 manufacturer of quality power supplies, with an entire lineup for all sorts of consumers.

Right now, we're only about a year into our PSU business and the HX was a home run for us (and many of our customers as well), so my goal, as the power supply applications specialist, is to make sure that the PSU products are absolutely bulletproof for generations to come.

And this forum, as well as JonnyGuru's forum and some other forums, as well as the fantastic feedback we get from guys like Mike here at SPCR, Kyle & Paul at HardOCP, Jonny Guru, and a few other guys always gives me the best ideas of what you guys want to buy.

I see it like this:
--You guys want a power supply that meets your needs.
--We'd love to sell you a power supply.
--We need to know what your needs and desires are for products.
--We can build those products if there's enough interest.

Sometimes I don't think you guys believe you have that much impact. But trust me, there are basically a small handful of guys here at Corsair that are in charge of which PSUs get made and what the next generation will be like. I'm one of them. So when you guys have comments or suggestions, the next-generation can be directly affected by them.

Like Mike pointed out at the end of his review, he wanted a lower-wattage product with similar efficiency and a lower price point, and we delivered.

So for any PSU comments or questions, or more info on it, I'm the power guy, powerguy@corsairmemory.com and I'll answer any questions you guys have.

Wow, that sounded like a sales pitch. Sorry.

Some time back I posted this:



For the most part this product hit the target. I'll take the VX450W fan curve and idle noise level as close enough to the S12-550E+.



The efficiency curve didn't hit all my targets but it did beat a few (40w and 300w). It hit most of the rest right on the target with only 90w being disappointing vs my lofty goals.

Apparently Corsair or Seasonic have gotten more conservative on marketing claims of effeciency. In the past the marketing claim would be 2 to 3% higher than the SPCR data showed. Now the claim matches the SPCR data to within a quarter of a percent. Even if they used the 230v number it would only be 86% not the 88% I imagined.

After seeing this quote I wonder what else they have up their sleeves.

Small typo on page 5 of the review:

Yay! Welcome back - SPCR has been slow since EPCR started.

A minor nitpick: above the graph on page 5, "extrapolated" should be "interpolated".

I'm still waiting for something like my old Silverstone 300W fanless PSU, except modular and 80+.

Mike and crew - thanks for the review!

Redbeard - Welcome to SPCR. Glad to see another vendor on board. Here's hoping your OEM relationship with Seasonic is fruitful over the long haul.

IMHO, this product hits the sweetspot for the average single video card build...I seldom see >200W while gaming with an overclocked e4300 and 8800gts. Heck, Corsair could bring out a VX300...but, the odd market misconceptions around actual power use would probably cause it to fail in the market.

Hi everybody,

Although I am an absolute noob on PSU's, I am learning o so fast here! But regarding this specific PSU I still have one question. I am currently in the process of assembling a new Game PC. Not an out-of-your-mind killer machine, but just a good solid system to suit my needs for the next few years. Among the main parts will be a Pentium Core2 Quad Q6600 processor and a NVidia Geforce 8800 GTS 320MB video card, all put together nicely on a Gigabyte P35-DS4 mainboard.

So for my question: will the Corsair VX450W suffice for this build?

Thanks in advance for your responses.
Stapper

yes

Welcome, stapper.

See the sticky "How much will a 300w power supply run?" discussion in the PSU forum.

Here's an example quote:

"Regardless, this is a beautiful machine, and now we know that a 300W single-fan PSU can power a rig with an nVidia GeForce 8800GTS, Intel E6600 CPU, Seagate 7200.10 HDD, Plextor SATA DVD Burner, Creative X-fi sound card, 4 fans, and 2 gigs of Mushkin PC-5300. Pretty slick."

450W would fall a bit short for a really kick-posterior games machine (hungry CPU, two very hungry GPUs) but suffice for anything less (e.g. dual nearly-top-of-the-range GPU.)

I would challenge you to prove that any system built on current technology would ever demand a power output above your current PSU lineup. With the current trend of power/watt, and power profiles comming down, larger PSU capacities seem to be opposite of current and future needs. Even with SLI setups (which btw have basically been proven to provide no real benefit and only seem to exist to sell aditional units to the wealthy), power requirements are still under 500-600w.

Dont forget about the average user, who's load is typically around 150-200w. A 300w psu would be more than adaquit for the majority of users out there.

Also id suggest you read MikeC's article on PSU thermal seperation to keep PSU fans from ramping up with increased system load. Such a setup favors an 80mm (front to back) airflow configuration over the current (popular) 120mm fan setups.

Though for lower noise, id prefer to have the 80mm fan on the opposite side it typically is now, pushing air over the PSU components and out the back, so theres less direct noise pathways from the fan to the user. This is really the only benefit 120mm currently have because their not located against the outside of the enlcosure.

==============================================

On a side note, i asked another company rep on this forum a few months ago for this, which i would consider the SPCR holy grail of power supplies.

An external passivly cooled 300w PSU brick with single output 12v rail, coupled with a custom made DC/DC converter to be used inside the system similar to a Pico-PSU.

If you think you hit a home run with your HX series, i guarentee a product like this would shadow that home run considerably.

I definitely agree with you on that one, I've been saying that for years.

And the whole not-so-pico-PSU might also be an interesting concept, but I'm not sure what the electronics behind it would be.

I'd just like to have a very cool running 250W PSU (twice the power my gaming rig draws) with high efficiencys even at "low" (100W) loads, that can nicely run passively.

a passive 300W brick? that's gonna have to be pretty efficient not to need a fan.