Is a fanless PC possible?
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
-
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Sun Apr 29, 2007 1:20 am
To build a fanless, modern(i.e dual core, high end graphics card) system is to do it for the challenge, rather than any audible gain.
As we've seen, systems like this take absurdly large heatsinks and a lot of DIY case modding to be made usable.
It is far easier to run an 120mm Nexus fan very slowly which, from far enough away(15+ inches), will be inaudible.
I'd suggest having the Nexus fan blowing out from the power supply onto the CPU heatsink(Ninja preferably) with airflow coming out through the front of the case(where you could elastic mount your HDD's). This would require a special case or at least some reorientation.
Easier still would be to stick quiet fans in all the usual places on your PC and remote desktop into it via a thin client, leaving the PC somewhere out of earshot.
As we've seen, systems like this take absurdly large heatsinks and a lot of DIY case modding to be made usable.
It is far easier to run an 120mm Nexus fan very slowly which, from far enough away(15+ inches), will be inaudible.
I'd suggest having the Nexus fan blowing out from the power supply onto the CPU heatsink(Ninja preferably) with airflow coming out through the front of the case(where you could elastic mount your HDD's). This would require a special case or at least some reorientation.
Easier still would be to stick quiet fans in all the usual places on your PC and remote desktop into it via a thin client, leaving the PC somewhere out of earshot.
not always:To build a fanless, modern(i.e dual core, high end graphics card) system is to do it for the challenge, rather than any audible gain.
As we've seen, systems like this take absurdly large heatsinks and a lot of DIY case modding to be made usable.
viewtopic.php?t=47075
admittedly the graphics in that setup is hardly cutting edge but then unless you are gaming it doesn't need to be.
-
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Sun Apr 29, 2007 1:20 am
jaganath, the thread you mentioned did indeed have a reasonably normal fanless system running, but...so what?
As someone else commented in the thread 63c for the CPU restart temperature in BIOS is very high. OK, so he can run his equipment fanless, but how long will it run at such temperatures.
Other than the thread you mentioned, who really wants to run their computer at dangerously high temperatures just so that it is fanless, there's no sense nor reason to do so.
As someone else commented in the thread 63c for the CPU restart temperature in BIOS is very high. OK, so he can run his equipment fanless, but how long will it run at such temperatures.
Other than the thread you mentioned, who really wants to run their computer at dangerously high temperatures just so that it is fanless, there's no sense nor reason to do so.
I just tried a fanless system to see how it works :
-Cooler master cosmos
-Seasonic M12
-Asus P5E-WS
-C2D 6320
-Passive Ninja rev.b
-Geforce 8800 gt with Accelero S1 rev.b
-Geil esoteric ddr2-1066
-WD800BEVS (2.5")
It isn't really a 100% fanless system as there is still the power supply fan, but it's inaudible and in the cosmos it doesn't suck air from the case like in most cases, so it has almost no effects. I think it would be the same with a passive psu.
Well, that system works quite well, is rock solid. Even pushig the fsb to 400, without changing voltage, it's 100% stable.
But even idle, it gets very, very hot.
During high loads, it's so hot that every heatsink (mb, gpu, cpu, ram) will burn your skin if you touch them! I had several burns on the fingers just by checking the heatsinks! cpu and gpu went over 70°c! I don't think that running a computer every days in that condition would be reasonable... But it works.
I will try a fanless system on another computer soon. It should be much more acceptable since cpu is a celeron conroe-l and mb has integrated graphics. Obviously, it's not the same performance level... I plan to use that computer as a NAS... I'll keep you informed!
-Cooler master cosmos
-Seasonic M12
-Asus P5E-WS
-C2D 6320
-Passive Ninja rev.b
-Geforce 8800 gt with Accelero S1 rev.b
-Geil esoteric ddr2-1066
-WD800BEVS (2.5")
It isn't really a 100% fanless system as there is still the power supply fan, but it's inaudible and in the cosmos it doesn't suck air from the case like in most cases, so it has almost no effects. I think it would be the same with a passive psu.
Well, that system works quite well, is rock solid. Even pushig the fsb to 400, without changing voltage, it's 100% stable.
But even idle, it gets very, very hot.
During high loads, it's so hot that every heatsink (mb, gpu, cpu, ram) will burn your skin if you touch them! I had several burns on the fingers just by checking the heatsinks! cpu and gpu went over 70°c! I don't think that running a computer every days in that condition would be reasonable... But it works.
I will try a fanless system on another computer soon. It should be much more acceptable since cpu is a celeron conroe-l and mb has integrated graphics. Obviously, it's not the same performance level... I plan to use that computer as a NAS... I'll keep you informed!
-
- Patron of SPCR
- Posts: 744
- Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2008 4:05 am
- Location: London
- Contact: