Hi y'all. Some notes taken from our techlib on fan placement. My reference for this is the following:
Steinberg, Dave S.. "Chapter 6 - Forced-Air Cooling for Electronics". Cooling
Techniques for Electronic Equipment, Second Edition. Professional Engineering
Publications. Â© 1991.
First snippet is on laminar versus turbulent flow:
Laminar flow conditions as well as turbulent flow conditions can exist with forced
convection in liquids and air. Turbulent flow conditions are much more desirable,
because they permit more heat to be removed. However, turbulent flow will usually result
in a higher pressure drop through the system, which requires that larger pumps and fans
and more power be used to overcome the added resistance.
Second is on fan placement:
The position of the fan blades within an axial flow fan housing can be a critical factor in
determining how well a fan will perform. This is especially important in high-speed fans
that have speeds greater than about 8000 rpm.
(Given the 8K rpm speed, I'm not sure how much of the following apply to SPCR readers). Continuing:
An examination of most high-speed axial flow fans will show that the fan blades are not
located at the center of the tubular housing but near one end. When the fan is located
adjacent to a restricted area, such as a 90Â° bend, the fan blades should be positioned so
that they are at the downstream end of the housing, for the best performance. Air has
weight and kinetic energy, so that the air velocity must be allowed to develop to
effectively overcome the flow resistance. When the fan blades are located at the
downstream end of the fan housing, the air has a slightly longer flow path. This improves
the velocity profile, as shown in Figures 6.3 and 6.4.
It makes no difference if a blowing or an exhaust fan system is used; the velocity profile
must have a chance to develop to provide an efficient air delivery system.
The reduced flow efficiency for the fan shown in Figure 6.4 will not be obvious to a
casual observer. When the fan is in operation, you can place your hand over the exhaust
and feel a large volume of air flowing through the fan. However, if a thin strip of paper is
slowly passed across the fan exhaust, it will show that some of the air is being shortcircuited.
The airflow at the outer perimeter of the fan will be moving away from the fan,
but the airflow at the center will be moving toward the fan, resulting in a short circuit, as
shown in Figure 6.5.
Some good fan installations and some poor ones are shown in Figure 6.6. Test data on
these types of installations have shown that the cooling airflow rate can be more than
doubled just by properly orienting the position of the fan blade within the fan housing
when the fan is located adjacent to an area that restricts the free flow of cooling air.
That's all for now, hope somebody found this info useful. I saw some posts in the gallery section where they had double-decked the fans (one emptied out), looks like they're headed in the correct direction. I will conduct some experiments when I get a chance.