Google to push for more electrical efficiency in PCs
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
Google to push for more electrical efficiency in PCs
Hey All,
I'm a long time reader, but never registered before. I saw this article and was suprized no one mentioned it here.
http://news.com.com/Google+to+push+for+ ... g=nefd.top
I thought the readers here would especially like this part:
Both the Google engineers and Calwell agreed that there was a significant design flaw, which they described as "overprovisioning," in today's PC power supplies. "It's like putting a 400-horsepower engine in every car, just because some cars have to tow large trailers every once in a while," Calwell said.
I'm a long time reader, but never registered before. I saw this article and was suprized no one mentioned it here.
http://news.com.com/Google+to+push+for+ ... g=nefd.top
I thought the readers here would especially like this part:
Both the Google engineers and Calwell agreed that there was a significant design flaw, which they described as "overprovisioning," in today's PC power supplies. "It's like putting a 400-horsepower engine in every car, just because some cars have to tow large trailers every once in a while," Calwell said.
http://forums.silentpcreview.com/viewto ... ght=google
Though we haven't seen the bit about PSU sizing before, good to hear.
Though we haven't seen the bit about PSU sizing before, good to hear.
-
- Friend of SPCR
- Posts: 502
- Joined: Sat Oct 23, 2004 2:02 pm
Google says that each PSU actually has four different PSUs in it. To be quite honest, they are wrong, you only need three, one to convert 120 Volt AC power into 12 Volt DC power and two to convert some of the 12 Volt DC power to 3.3 Volt DC power and 5 Volt DC power, which both have very small loads in the majority of computers. An excellent example of this would be the picoPSU review:
http://www.silentpcreview.com/article601-page1.html
The only thing is that to my knowledge, no computer PSU manufacturer has created the functional equivalent of the picoPSU in a conventional PC form factor. I am glad to see that at least one company is pushing to get this changed.
http://www.silentpcreview.com/article601-page1.html
The only thing is that to my knowledge, no computer PSU manufacturer has created the functional equivalent of the picoPSU in a conventional PC form factor. I am glad to see that at least one company is pushing to get this changed.
-
- Posts: 1608
- Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2005 4:02 pm
- Location: United States
I know there have been at least a few discussions on SPCR about using single-rail power supplies in desktop systems. Looks like this is about to turn into another one.
I think there are many advantages to a single-rail power system. I do question the efficiency gains, however. I'd imagine (at least initially) many of the voltage outputs would not be eliminated, but simply moved from the power supply to the motherboard. For example, don't many simple ICs (voltage regulators, etc.) still operate on +5V bias (isn't this kind of a "legacy" voltage)? So then you have to consider, what would be more efficient, a high quality power supply that has multiple outputs, or a high quality power supply with one output and a low quality motherboard with multiple outputs.
But then again, if a +12V power system became standard, I'd assume motherboard, HDD, etc. manufacturers would start using components designed to operate at +12V (I'd assume such devices exist), so it's kind of a moot point. Just something to consider, though.
Some definite advantages. Simplicity, and therefore lower cost and size. Potentially higher efficiency and therefore less power consumption, heat, noise, etc.
EDIT: Cool, 1k posts.
I think there are many advantages to a single-rail power system. I do question the efficiency gains, however. I'd imagine (at least initially) many of the voltage outputs would not be eliminated, but simply moved from the power supply to the motherboard. For example, don't many simple ICs (voltage regulators, etc.) still operate on +5V bias (isn't this kind of a "legacy" voltage)? So then you have to consider, what would be more efficient, a high quality power supply that has multiple outputs, or a high quality power supply with one output and a low quality motherboard with multiple outputs.
But then again, if a +12V power system became standard, I'd assume motherboard, HDD, etc. manufacturers would start using components designed to operate at +12V (I'd assume such devices exist), so it's kind of a moot point. Just something to consider, though.
Some definite advantages. Simplicity, and therefore lower cost and size. Potentially higher efficiency and therefore less power consumption, heat, noise, etc.
EDIT: Cool, 1k posts.
-
- Friend of SPCR
- Posts: 502
- Joined: Sat Oct 23, 2004 2:02 pm
They developed this single rail power supply system to power the servers that run their search engine. Now they want to share this approach with the rest of the PC industry for PR purposes.NyteOwl wrote:Call me the odd man out, but Google needs to go back to doing what it does well - operating a search engine. It's getting altogether too intrusive for my tastes.
And yes I'm in a lousy mood at the moment.