Antec MX-1: Actively Cooled External HDD Enclosure
-
- Posts: 1386
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 6:53 pm
I've got the enclosure, and while I won't say it's quiet, it's one of the quieter enclosures out there. For that reason alone I will not be returning. Returning it would only make sense if there was something better. So while there was definitely room for improvement by using a better fan, it's still the quietest enclosure I've used (save for completely passive ones), so I decided to keep mine.
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
Why don't you call/email Antec tech support and see what they say when you complain about the fan noise.Jumper wrote:No. I was planning on returning it to Newegg...Ralf Hutter wrote:Has anyone with a "loud fanned" MX-1 enclosure contacted Antec tech support or customer service about this issue?
Part of me says "return it to Antec" though, because then their engineers can look at it and see what is up....
-
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 2:55 pm
- Location: on your GPS
I've got two MX-1s, one fan is definitely louder than the other. They were both bought at the same time in UK. It's slightly annoying purely because of the frequency but I tend to use the louder one for backups.
I'm just about to buy a couple more, based on the fact no one else has a better solution. Plus I've not been impressed by the quality of other enclosures recently. I also blew an Akasa up too...but that's another story!
I hope I might cop lucky on the fans.
I'm just about to buy a couple more, based on the fact no one else has a better solution. Plus I've not been impressed by the quality of other enclosures recently. I also blew an Akasa up too...but that's another story!
I hope I might cop lucky on the fans.
I think having a 3.5" external is not such a strange idea for laptop users. Many people have no desktop computer, only a laptop, and the advantage is that you don't need a desk for it. So with a 3.5" external you can still have a > 250GB media collection (the largest mobile usb-powered harddisk I've seen is now 250GB). But if it wasn't for the size you'd be better off with a mobile 2.5", I concur.
-
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 2:55 pm
- Location: on your GPS
I've just got my two new units and have been checking out the fan on one of them, independently of any drive. It's difficult to tell right now but tonally it appears similar to the noisier one of the two I already had. So slightly disappointing. I'll try the other unit tomorrow.
As they will predominantly backup drives that won't be continously running for long stretches such noise is just about bearable.
When I purchased seven months ago, I was probably fortunate to receive one quiet unit out of two. That one I do keep running throughout the day.
I really think Antec need to take a look at the fans. I notice there's no reference to dBA on any of the box packaging (new or old). Is it still on any of their datasheets?
It's a shame about this because the product is otherwise A1. If only they were a generic component that could be simply replaced. I think the blade width is 10mm, is that what they use in 80x80x15mm units? I guess it's not that simple.
But it is the only enclosure that I've bought or seen in the last 18mths that firmly holds the drive in place. From what I can tell the general quality of caddies has gone right down. Or the OEMs have got carried away with aluminium everything and made them, if anything, noisier.
As they will predominantly backup drives that won't be continously running for long stretches such noise is just about bearable.
When I purchased seven months ago, I was probably fortunate to receive one quiet unit out of two. That one I do keep running throughout the day.
I really think Antec need to take a look at the fans. I notice there's no reference to dBA on any of the box packaging (new or old). Is it still on any of their datasheets?
It's a shame about this because the product is otherwise A1. If only they were a generic component that could be simply replaced. I think the blade width is 10mm, is that what they use in 80x80x15mm units? I guess it's not that simple.
But it is the only enclosure that I've bought or seen in the last 18mths that firmly holds the drive in place. From what I can tell the general quality of caddies has gone right down. Or the OEMs have got carried away with aluminium everything and made them, if anything, noisier.
Maybe it would be a good idea if SPCR put a little notice on the main article about these things, cause if you're just comparing products you're (I am) not likely to check out the discussion here, so people may end up buying something that is not quiet at all before discovering that that was quite well known on these forums.
-
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 2:55 pm
- Location: on your GPS
I think it probably is worth putting a 'fair warning' with the article. I wouldn't say the fan is loud in itself but the tone it produces is. A contradictory statement I suppose but that's the best way I can explain it.
Perhaps SPCR could contact Antec on our behalf to find out what the fan situation is as clearly there has been no substantial change/improvement in units over the last 6mths.
It just seems to be a case of rolling the dice and hope you are lucky. IMO that isn't good enough for a what is marketed as a premium product.
I have got two cheap and cheerful Sumvision eSata units but they do run hot and are not secured as well as I would like. After a disaster with an Akasa Integral this, for me, made the MX-1 the only viable choice or take a punt in another direction.
Perhaps SPCR could contact Antec on our behalf to find out what the fan situation is as clearly there has been no substantial change/improvement in units over the last 6mths.
It just seems to be a case of rolling the dice and hope you are lucky. IMO that isn't good enough for a what is marketed as a premium product.
I have got two cheap and cheerful Sumvision eSata units but they do run hot and are not secured as well as I would like. After a disaster with an Akasa Integral this, for me, made the MX-1 the only viable choice or take a punt in another direction.
-
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 2:55 pm
- Location: on your GPS
I just got mine. It is definitely one of the chainsaw loud ones. I'm not even in a quiet room and i can definitely hear it from 2 metres away. Louder than the drive itself (which is several years old). Very dissapointed. I've bought heaps of Antec products in the past. It's definitely not the same product that Mike got to review. I just hope he bought it and a "cherry picked" version wasn't given to Mike by Antec.
http://www.antec.com/us/productDetails.php?ProdID=77150IdontexistM8 wrote:
I really think Antec need to take a look at the fans. I notice there's no reference to dBA on any of the box packaging (new or old). Is it still on any of their datasheets?
Quotes 20dbA with lid closed. Mine certainly isn't
Yes I agree with you. It's a great product except for the noise. I contacted Antec and they said they weren't aware of fan issues and that I could replace it if necessary but I'll probably get another equally noisy unit. I suspect they have quietly (or not so quietly) changed suppliers. I was planning on using the enclosure to house my primary hard drive but now I'll probably get another primary drive and use it just as a backup.
Product is highly not recommended for silent PC use for me
just got a noisy one
i just received my "chainsaw" today...i wish that i had found this article before purchasing. i had read the review but somehow this thread escaped me.
this is way, way louder than my WD MyBook external drive.
now i have to decide on whether to return or roll the dice on an exchange
peace
this is way, way louder than my WD MyBook external drive.
now i have to decide on whether to return or roll the dice on an exchange
peace
-
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 2:55 pm
- Location: on your GPS
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
from the wiki
Where a PC-hosted port is concerned, eSATA connectors cannot supply power, and would therefore be more cumbersome to use.
but also:
From the second half of 2008, SATA-IO expects eSATA to provide power to eSATA devices without the need for a separate power connection. In a news release from 2008-01-14, SATA-IO calls it the "Power Over eSATA initiative."
Where a PC-hosted port is concerned, eSATA connectors cannot supply power, and would therefore be more cumbersome to use.
but also:
From the second half of 2008, SATA-IO expects eSATA to provide power to eSATA devices without the need for a separate power connection. In a news release from 2008-01-14, SATA-IO calls it the "Power Over eSATA initiative."
Myth, What they're saying is that current implementations of eSATA require a power connector. The next generation of this connector "Power Over eSATA" will not. Therefore you require power with the mx1Myth! wrote:from the wiki
Where a PC-hosted port is concerned, eSATA connectors cannot supply power, and would therefore be more cumbersome to use.
but also:
From the second half of 2008, SATA-IO expects eSATA to provide power to eSATA devices without the need for a separate power connection. In a news release from 2008-01-14, SATA-IO calls it the "Power Over eSATA initiative."
Hmm. Now that I've been using it for a bit, The fan is not nearly as noticeable when a meter away, and with it installed in place.
I do like how well it dampens HDD noise and vibrations. I have a 7200.11 1TB SATA drive in it, and it's pretty quiet (not silent, but it's pretty good).
If the room is totally silent, I can just barely hear the fan buzz. I'd like to see if it's possible to swap the fan out with a quieter one. Was wondering if any possible fan would fit.
-Ed
I do like how well it dampens HDD noise and vibrations. I have a 7200.11 1TB SATA drive in it, and it's pretty quiet (not silent, but it's pretty good).
If the room is totally silent, I can just barely hear the fan buzz. I'd like to see if it's possible to swap the fan out with a quieter one. Was wondering if any possible fan would fit.
-Ed
I'm going to chime in on this. I bought my MX-1 already last year and I have to agree, it's terribly loud especially compared to my computer.
Few weeks ago I changed my external hard drive to WD GP. Somehow I managed to hit the fan connector. It has really poor connection, so the fan stopped spinning. Before I knew it, my WD GP was baking as drive temps quickly rose above 55 degrees.
WD GP was also dissapointing. I was hoping for quiet seeks, but when the drive is installed in MX-1 it has louder seeks then my 150GB inside SQD. And I'm not exaggerating. The seeks inside MX-1 are nasty hollow. I already regret I didn't buy a Samsung, although I blame MX-1 more.
I almost regret purchasing MX-1. Luckily I only have to listen to it, when I do a hard drive image with Norton Ghost.
Few weeks ago I changed my external hard drive to WD GP. Somehow I managed to hit the fan connector. It has really poor connection, so the fan stopped spinning. Before I knew it, my WD GP was baking as drive temps quickly rose above 55 degrees.
WD GP was also dissapointing. I was hoping for quiet seeks, but when the drive is installed in MX-1 it has louder seeks then my 150GB inside SQD. And I'm not exaggerating. The seeks inside MX-1 are nasty hollow. I already regret I didn't buy a Samsung, although I blame MX-1 more.
I almost regret purchasing MX-1. Luckily I only have to listen to it, when I do a hard drive image with Norton Ghost.
I own a MX1, SQD, WD GP and a samsung 2504. My samsung is definitely not quieter than the WD GP. I've already expressed my disappointment with the Antec MX-1 acoustically earlier in this thread. I didn't return it because it's not worth the trouble but i regret buying it. The MX1 would do nothing for quieting seek noise and may actually amplify it whereas the sqd dampens it somewhat . the samsung would be slightly worse. Have you tried the WD GP and SQD combination? It's the best combination i've found. (just don't expect miracles). Inside a case mounted on soft feet or sorbathane i'd call it close to inaudibleErssa wrote: WD GP was also dissapointing. I was hoping for quiet seeks, but when the drive is installed in MX-1 it has louder seeks then my 150GB inside SQD. And I'm not exaggerating. The seeks inside MX-1 are nasty hollow. I already regret I didn't buy a Samsung, although I blame MX-1 more.
I actually had T166 320GB Samsung in MX-1 before I bought GP. I don't recall my Samsung ever sounding so nasty. Idle noise doesn't matter, since the fan is louder. Before I had my MX-1 on top of my case. Now with GP, I have even placed it on 5 cms of foam, in futile effort to silence the seeks.Immortals wrote:I own a MX1, SQD, WD GP and a samsung 2504. My samsung is definitely not quieter than the WD GP. I've already expressed my disappointment with the Antec MX-1 acoustically earlier in this thread. I didn't return it because it's not worth the trouble but i regret buying it. The MX1 would do nothing for quieting seek noise and may actually amplify it whereas the sqd dampens it somewhat . the samsung would be slightly worse.
Yes, I know SQD is not a miracle worker. It was quite the disappointment when I bought it. Imo it's not worth trying to put GP in SQD. It's way too slow for me to use it as a primary hard drive. I bought it just to replace my Samsung as external backup device. I also dislike the SQD, because it makes drives sound hard mounted and it's so big, that effective soft mounting is pretty much impossible. At least with my previous 2 cases.
-
- Posts: 424
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 9:08 pm
- Location: Somewhere over the rainbow....
I'm going to chime in too
I bought this enclosure a couple days ago b/c of the sale at fry's (going for 29 bucks)
I bought it more on a whim since I remembered the SPCR review on it and to accompany the 750gb seagate drive I just bought too
I'm going to agree that this is louder than expected, while I don't think it's a chainsaw, it definitely has become the loudest computer equipment, surpassing my 4 year old system....
I agree it's more of the tonal noise that is annoying, and the silicone gasket doesn't do much for the vibration reduction
I bought this enclosure a couple days ago b/c of the sale at fry's (going for 29 bucks)
I bought it more on a whim since I remembered the SPCR review on it and to accompany the 750gb seagate drive I just bought too
I'm going to agree that this is louder than expected, while I don't think it's a chainsaw, it definitely has become the loudest computer equipment, surpassing my 4 year old system....
I agree it's more of the tonal noise that is annoying, and the silicone gasket doesn't do much for the vibration reduction
MX-1 continues to disappoint me. Noise aside.. there is some serious QC issues.
I forgot to turn it off last night after a backup. The hard drive WD5000AAKS was baked and was hot to touch.
Turns out the fan stopped spinning. Now it won't spin if you turn the unit on without an hdd installed. Seriously, wtf antec.
I forgot to turn it off last night after a backup. The hard drive WD5000AAKS was baked and was hot to touch.
Turns out the fan stopped spinning. Now it won't spin if you turn the unit on without an hdd installed. Seriously, wtf antec.