0dBA Project rev.2
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
0dBA Project rev.2
First off, to make further explanations easier: here's a link to rev.1 [Babelfish translation, not of much use though].
And here's the successor:
S AM2 A64 3000+ 2000 @ 2600, 1.55v
Gigabyte GA-M55plus-S3G
Corsair XMS2x512 5400Pro
Leadtek PX7900GT TDH Extreme 520\375 @ 580\440
FSP FX600GLN
2 notebook drives
- Design -
Unlike rev.1, which was a real bitch to take apart, this comp was intended to be more user friendly. Which meant - no external heatsinks. This concept led to PSU relocation, to prevent it from being heated up by the CPU HS. Plus, originally there was no room for the VGA HS inside the case so 3.5' drive cages had to go. This layout required an uncommonly wide case, luckily I was able to find one.
- Components & mods -
1. CPU Cooling
This was the easiest part, thanks to Scythe Inc. All I had to do was to mod the retention mechanism in order to provide the Ninja with AM2 compatibility.
2. Mobo.
Heatsinks were glued to VRM mosfets and all other mosfets I could lay my hands on - just in case.
The NB cooling system uses two heatpipes and two heat blocks taken from Tt Shooner. The upper block is to be bolted to a... hmm... external heatsink but I managed to make a quick-release coupling so it's ok. The original plan was to use a modded (increased fin spacing) CM Blue Ice 2, but that idea turned out to be nothing but a waste of money. The small heatsink didn't make it - it was literally suffocating, squeezed into a tight gap between the vidcard and the Ninja. BTW, always use shims when working with heatpipes on naked dies. This is the second mobo, the first one lies cold and dead with it's NB chipped.
3. VGA Cooling.
Here's the first revision. Lacks some parts but the design can be seen more clearly.
Two copper heat blocks are self-machined, 5mm pipes were taken from a ZM-2HC2, 6mm ones - from two CM CoolVivas. Fins came from a Igloo 7700. The final version looks like this:
Apart from other enhancements, it has ramsinks (not visible on the picture) which are really a must for overclocked GDDR3 memory. The whole assembly weighs over 2 kilos so I had to add a support (several PCB standoffs bolted together). The vidcard's VRM required extra cooling as well:
4. Power Supply.
Formerly it was an Epsilon FX600GLN. The fan was thrown away, case was chopped by 1cm to fit the desired location.
Heatpipes - Tt Shooner
Fins - CM Blue Ice II.
Beware everyone: in Epsilons there are no dielectric pads between transistors and their sinks so two of the three heatsinks carry 300v. Whatever you would want to attach to them MUST be insulated from PSU case or any grounded parts.
5. Hard drives.
Nothing special here, the whole assembly was taken from 0dB rev.1
The foam box houses two 2.5' PATA drives: a 20Gb Seagate and a 80Gb Samsung.
6. Case
No idea who the manufacurer is, the only writing on the box was "small server case". It required some dremel work: cutting out openings in the top and bottom panels to aid natural convection.
- Assembling -
Ninja and vidcard in place.
NB heat block bolted to the external heatsink.
The external heatsink itself.
PSU fin guard (formerly a CM Hyper 6 fan shroud). It serves two purposes: to protect the flimsy fins from cables sticking out of the computer's back and to protect the careless user from 300v residing on the fins.
PSU in place.
Drives in place.
General view.
Back side view
Bottom view. The combination of wheels and feet allows the case to be easily pulled out from under the table but prevents it from rolling by itself.
That's it for now, ask your questions if you want more details.
And here's the successor:
S AM2 A64 3000+ 2000 @ 2600, 1.55v
Gigabyte GA-M55plus-S3G
Corsair XMS2x512 5400Pro
Leadtek PX7900GT TDH Extreme 520\375 @ 580\440
FSP FX600GLN
2 notebook drives
- Design -
Unlike rev.1, which was a real bitch to take apart, this comp was intended to be more user friendly. Which meant - no external heatsinks. This concept led to PSU relocation, to prevent it from being heated up by the CPU HS. Plus, originally there was no room for the VGA HS inside the case so 3.5' drive cages had to go. This layout required an uncommonly wide case, luckily I was able to find one.
- Components & mods -
1. CPU Cooling
This was the easiest part, thanks to Scythe Inc. All I had to do was to mod the retention mechanism in order to provide the Ninja with AM2 compatibility.
2. Mobo.
Heatsinks were glued to VRM mosfets and all other mosfets I could lay my hands on - just in case.
The NB cooling system uses two heatpipes and two heat blocks taken from Tt Shooner. The upper block is to be bolted to a... hmm... external heatsink but I managed to make a quick-release coupling so it's ok. The original plan was to use a modded (increased fin spacing) CM Blue Ice 2, but that idea turned out to be nothing but a waste of money. The small heatsink didn't make it - it was literally suffocating, squeezed into a tight gap between the vidcard and the Ninja. BTW, always use shims when working with heatpipes on naked dies. This is the second mobo, the first one lies cold and dead with it's NB chipped.
3. VGA Cooling.
Here's the first revision. Lacks some parts but the design can be seen more clearly.
Two copper heat blocks are self-machined, 5mm pipes were taken from a ZM-2HC2, 6mm ones - from two CM CoolVivas. Fins came from a Igloo 7700. The final version looks like this:
Apart from other enhancements, it has ramsinks (not visible on the picture) which are really a must for overclocked GDDR3 memory. The whole assembly weighs over 2 kilos so I had to add a support (several PCB standoffs bolted together). The vidcard's VRM required extra cooling as well:
4. Power Supply.
Formerly it was an Epsilon FX600GLN. The fan was thrown away, case was chopped by 1cm to fit the desired location.
Heatpipes - Tt Shooner
Fins - CM Blue Ice II.
Beware everyone: in Epsilons there are no dielectric pads between transistors and their sinks so two of the three heatsinks carry 300v. Whatever you would want to attach to them MUST be insulated from PSU case or any grounded parts.
5. Hard drives.
Nothing special here, the whole assembly was taken from 0dB rev.1
The foam box houses two 2.5' PATA drives: a 20Gb Seagate and a 80Gb Samsung.
6. Case
No idea who the manufacurer is, the only writing on the box was "small server case". It required some dremel work: cutting out openings in the top and bottom panels to aid natural convection.
- Assembling -
Ninja and vidcard in place.
NB heat block bolted to the external heatsink.
The external heatsink itself.
PSU fin guard (formerly a CM Hyper 6 fan shroud). It serves two purposes: to protect the flimsy fins from cables sticking out of the computer's back and to protect the careless user from 300v residing on the fins.
PSU in place.
Drives in place.
General view.
Back side view
Bottom view. The combination of wheels and feet allows the case to be easily pulled out from under the table but prevents it from rolling by itself.
That's it for now, ask your questions if you want more details.
Last edited by EndoSteel on Mon Sep 25, 2006 7:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
Damn, that's impressive. The temps are a little higher than I'd be comfortable with, though. Especially because my apartment can hit 38C in the summer...
Where is that case situated? I'd be interested to see how airflow in the room and around the case affects the cooling. Perhaps there could be a way to get natural airflow (besides just convection) to go in through the bottom and out through the top...
Cheers!
Where is that case situated? I'd be interested to see how airflow in the room and around the case affects the cooling. Perhaps there could be a way to get natural airflow (besides just convection) to go in through the bottom and out through the top...
Cheers!
-
- Patron of SPCR
- Posts: 857
- Joined: Fri Dec 27, 2002 1:49 pm
- Location: Somerset, WI - USA
- Contact:
Cool, you used the same PSU layout that I've been thinking of using for a custom case. See here. Although I wasn't thinking fanless. Nice work!
Have you thought about using electrically-insulated thermal pads between the PSU HS and the heat pipes? That way you don't have 300V sitting outside your case.
Have you thought about using electrically-insulated thermal pads between the PSU HS and the heat pipes? That way you don't have 300V sitting outside your case.
grepcomputers
Where is that case situated? I'd be interested to see how airflow in the room and around the case affects the cooling.
Actually it's hard to imagine a worse place for a passive system . The niche is open from front and back but that's not enough to maintain good convectional airflow: had to drill vent holes in one of the side panels (you can see them in the picture).
BillyBuerger
Have you thought about using electrically-insulated thermal pads between the PSU HS and the heat pipes? That way you don't have 300V sitting outside your case.
Had considered that, but couldn't construct a retension mechanism that would not have been a complete PITA to put together.
silon
having the capability [and the guts] to cut heatsinks apart and machine blocks of copper and so on is so much fun!
Yup . The downside is I can't cook food in my kitchen any more:
Ryan
Hmm.. wouldn't even a single low rpm fan like a nexus get you like, 208370287304827034 degeres better while s till being almost 0db ?
You're right, but I like challenging tasks .
justblair
Just one thing... That heatsink in the shroud at the back is live?
I would be thinking about a more complete shroud than that...
There's no way I can touch the sink from where I'm sitting and I don't have pets.
BTW, 300v don't kill, I tried .
Where is that case situated? I'd be interested to see how airflow in the room and around the case affects the cooling.
Actually it's hard to imagine a worse place for a passive system . The niche is open from front and back but that's not enough to maintain good convectional airflow: had to drill vent holes in one of the side panels (you can see them in the picture).
BillyBuerger
Have you thought about using electrically-insulated thermal pads between the PSU HS and the heat pipes? That way you don't have 300V sitting outside your case.
Had considered that, but couldn't construct a retension mechanism that would not have been a complete PITA to put together.
silon
having the capability [and the guts] to cut heatsinks apart and machine blocks of copper and so on is so much fun!
Yup . The downside is I can't cook food in my kitchen any more:
Ryan
Hmm.. wouldn't even a single low rpm fan like a nexus get you like, 208370287304827034 degeres better while s till being almost 0db ?
You're right, but I like challenging tasks .
justblair
Just one thing... That heatsink in the shroud at the back is live?
I would be thinking about a more complete shroud than that...
There's no way I can touch the sink from where I'm sitting and I don't have pets.
BTW, 300v don't kill, I tried .
ROFL
You are quite mad... In a nice way of course!
You can say that you have suffered for your art.
I dislike being zapped. I took a 240v jolt straight off the mains supply a while back and it hurt like hell. The following day was the worst, my arm just ached and ached. There is nothing quite like that sensation.
You are quite mad... In a nice way of course!
You can say that you have suffered for your art.
I dislike being zapped. I took a 240v jolt straight off the mains supply a while back and it hurt like hell. The following day was the worst, my arm just ached and ached. There is nothing quite like that sensation.
-
- Posts: 436
- Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2006 8:15 pm
- Location: Michigan
-
- *Lifetime Patron*
- Posts: 288
- Joined: Sat Oct 22, 2005 10:39 am
Excellent!
I'm guessing your counting on the fact that the PSU is rated for 600W to assume that the internal components not connected to any heatsinks, (i.e. usually relying on fan airflow only) will not never reach high temps given that your system load is prolly less than 250W.
Which is prolly why you mounted the psu at the bottom, good choice . I wouldn't feel safe having all the heat from the other components channeled upwards into a psu with the fan removed.
Good job.
Also, your psu is the "FX600-GLN" I believe, you omitted the dash. (I don't care much for spelling personally, but it will help future spcr readers find your article
I'm guessing your counting on the fact that the PSU is rated for 600W to assume that the internal components not connected to any heatsinks, (i.e. usually relying on fan airflow only) will not never reach high temps given that your system load is prolly less than 250W.
Which is prolly why you mounted the psu at the bottom, good choice . I wouldn't feel safe having all the heat from the other components channeled upwards into a psu with the fan removed.
Good job.
Also, your psu is the "FX600-GLN" I believe, you omitted the dash. (I don't care much for spelling personally, but it will help future spcr readers find your article
cloneman
I'm guessing your counting on the fact that the PSU is rated for 600W to assume that the internal components not connected to any heatsinks, (i.e. usually relying on fan airflow only) will not never reach high temps given that your system load is prolly less than 250W.
Not exactly. Internal components' temps usually depend more on circuit design than output wattage. But transistors and diodes rated for higher currents can withstand higher temps at the same load than lower current ones.
Which is prolly why you mounted the psu at the bottom, good choice . I wouldn't feel safe having all the heat from the other components channeled upwards into a psu with the fan removed.
Yup.
I'm guessing your counting on the fact that the PSU is rated for 600W to assume that the internal components not connected to any heatsinks, (i.e. usually relying on fan airflow only) will not never reach high temps given that your system load is prolly less than 250W.
Not exactly. Internal components' temps usually depend more on circuit design than output wattage. But transistors and diodes rated for higher currents can withstand higher temps at the same load than lower current ones.
Which is prolly why you mounted the psu at the bottom, good choice . I wouldn't feel safe having all the heat from the other components channeled upwards into a psu with the fan removed.
Yup.
-
- Posts: 66
- Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2006 8:00 am
- Location: Detroit Metro Area
Nice...
That's a sweet silent setup. It also looks like you've done me a favor by confirming the Scythe Ninja will fit on the GA-M55plus-S3G. That's the board and HSF I want to use. Thanks!
You might be able to lower the temps inside some with one of those new and expensive 35W 3800+ X2's though.
You might be able to lower the temps inside some with one of those new and expensive 35W 3800+ X2's though.
-
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 12:26 am
- Location: Ontario, Canada