GOAL - Air cooling with no fans (edit: GOAL reached)
Moderators: Ralf Hutter, Lawrence Lee
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
GOAL - Air cooling with no fans (edit: GOAL reached)
I'm not going to tell (at least not yet) you what new green idea i just tested.
All guessing and ideas are allowed, i hope this review starts an interesting green conversation.
In this little review I show some unbelievable results (i was waiting for just 5 degrees drop...) and tell you exactly what I didn't do.
I hope we all start to think about new ideas how to make things the green way.
What would you do, under the same limits, to achieve similar results?
System: read my signature or read my General Gallery post viewtopic.php?t=57320
Setup in this review: 2 Fans with locked speed. CPU overclocked from 9x333MHz to 9x404MHz (22%). Memory overclocked from DDR2 667MHz to DDR2 808MHz.
First set of images
Locked fan speeds:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com//ima ... _30min.jpg
Burning: with those fan speeds i did let my system get a bit hot...
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _30min.jpg
Steady voltage: Burning didn't affect Abit X38 quadGT voltages
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _30min.jpg
And here are the things i didn't do to achieve the following result
- I didn't add/remove/start/stop anything that consumes power
- I didn't open the case (P182)
- I didn't move the case
- I didn't block or open any intakes/exhausts, doors, filters etc.
- I didn't use any software
- I didn't change any settings
- Room temperature didn't change (21C)
I did stop the burn just for 1 sec to mark the spot in the graph when i did the mod.
Here's the next set of images:
9 minutes of temperatures after the change:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _10min.jpg
And here's the temperatures after 45 mins, 100% CPU+FSU burn still going on. I suppose it's quite as low as it gets with this mod.
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _45min.jpg
Just to make sure the fan speeds are still the same:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _45min.jpg
So, I did manage to:
- drop my highest PWM temperature (pwm3) 16 degrees
- drop CPU temperature 11 degrees
- drop GPU temp 7 degrees (note: GPU was not stressed)
- drop system temperature 5 degrees
What was my MOD ?
All guessing and ideas are allowed, i hope this review starts an interesting green conversation.
In this little review I show some unbelievable results (i was waiting for just 5 degrees drop...) and tell you exactly what I didn't do.
I hope we all start to think about new ideas how to make things the green way.
What would you do, under the same limits, to achieve similar results?
System: read my signature or read my General Gallery post viewtopic.php?t=57320
Setup in this review: 2 Fans with locked speed. CPU overclocked from 9x333MHz to 9x404MHz (22%). Memory overclocked from DDR2 667MHz to DDR2 808MHz.
First set of images
Locked fan speeds:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com//ima ... _30min.jpg
Burning: with those fan speeds i did let my system get a bit hot...
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _30min.jpg
Steady voltage: Burning didn't affect Abit X38 quadGT voltages
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _30min.jpg
And here are the things i didn't do to achieve the following result
- I didn't add/remove/start/stop anything that consumes power
- I didn't open the case (P182)
- I didn't move the case
- I didn't block or open any intakes/exhausts, doors, filters etc.
- I didn't use any software
- I didn't change any settings
- Room temperature didn't change (21C)
I did stop the burn just for 1 sec to mark the spot in the graph when i did the mod.
Here's the next set of images:
9 minutes of temperatures after the change:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _10min.jpg
And here's the temperatures after 45 mins, 100% CPU+FSU burn still going on. I suppose it's quite as low as it gets with this mod.
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _45min.jpg
Just to make sure the fan speeds are still the same:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com/imag ... _45min.jpg
So, I did manage to:
- drop my highest PWM temperature (pwm3) 16 degrees
- drop CPU temperature 11 degrees
- drop GPU temp 7 degrees (note: GPU was not stressed)
- drop system temperature 5 degrees
What was my MOD ?
Last edited by maalitehdas on Thu Feb 18, 2010 6:20 am, edited 3 times in total.
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
Per the Forum Rules, no pics over 640 pixels wide are allowed:
Thank you from your friendly mods!
Could you please resize your pics, or at least place a link to them instead?Forum Rule #13 wrote:Don't post big images, post links to them instead - images larger than 640 x 480 pixels have the effect of making pages so wide that lateral scrolling is required. This can make a page a real nuisance to scroll through. Please avoid posting such large images; a link works just as well even if it not quite as compelling or dramatic as the pic. Again, posts may be deleted without warning, and offenders banned, after ONE warning.
Thank you from your friendly mods!
-
- -- Vendor --
- Posts: 372
- Joined: Sun Jul 12, 2009 10:30 am
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Fri Jan 08, 2010 10:30 pm
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
Sorry for that. I did try to reduce the size, but they were nor readable any more, so i changed them all as links. They open very fast since it's only 120kb per picture.Ralf Hutter wrote:Per the Forum Rules, no pics over 640 pixels wide are allowed:
Could you please resize your pics, or at least place a link to them instead?Forum Rule #13 wrote:Don't post big images, post links to them instead - images larger than 640 x 480 pixels have the effect of making pages so wide that lateral scrolling is required. This can make a page a real nuisance to scroll through. Please avoid posting such large images; a link works just as well even if it not quite as compelling or dramatic as the pic. Again, posts may be deleted without warning, and offenders banned, after ONE warning.
Thank you from your friendly mods!
Absolutely right, green PC users should not overclock. Well, if you occasionally need extra power, maybe it's better to overclock instead of buying a new component? I usually run my system with 2,4GHz (normal 3,0GHz), in this test the overclocking was done just for the test. I couldn't get my system hot enough with normal processor speed. So, after the test it's back on 2,4GHZ and GREEN. Next test is if I can remove both fans with this clock speed, even more green.By overclocking you need more energy for unit of calculation so is not green.
Last edited by maalitehdas on Mon Feb 22, 2010 9:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
I coudn't, since i didn't open the case. Here's an image from inside the case, so nothing was changed in there (case was closed both before and after the mod)frenchie wrote:Did you move the fans around ?
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com//ima ... tup800.jpg
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
GOAL REACHED
Underclocking to 1,8GHz works with passive air cooling and with my peculiar mod - I have now removed all fans from the case (PSU fan is only one still running, how to get rid of that too?)
Temperatures:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com//ima ... ve_mod.jpg
Some test results from Everest 5.30:
CPU queen: 7594 points
CPU Photoworks: 10451 points
CPU ZLib 23196kb/s
CPU usage during HD-playback: 27-32%
Power consumption:
IDLE about 72W, LOAD unknown
Underclocking to 1,8GHz works with passive air cooling and with my peculiar mod - I have now removed all fans from the case (PSU fan is only one still running, how to get rid of that too?)
Temperatures:
http://maalitehdas.wippiespace.com//ima ... ve_mod.jpg
Some test results from Everest 5.30:
CPU queen: 7594 points
CPU Photoworks: 10451 points
CPU ZLib 23196kb/s
CPU usage during HD-playback: 27-32%
Power consumption:
IDLE about 72W, LOAD unknown
Last edited by maalitehdas on Tue Feb 23, 2010 12:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
That would be rare here, during 20 years i remember only two or three days over 30C. At the moment there's -10C outside.
About this power consumption, i've read that E8400 draws alone some 22W-30W from idle to load. FPU i don't know at all. Readings i get are PWM current, idle is 6A and load is 24A or 30A depending if i load CPU or FPU. Is it possible to use PWM current amps to calculate whole system power consumption?
About this power consumption, i've read that E8400 draws alone some 22W-30W from idle to load. FPU i don't know at all. Readings i get are PWM current, idle is 6A and load is 24A or 30A depending if i load CPU or FPU. Is it possible to use PWM current amps to calculate whole system power consumption?
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
I must give you and others a hint at least:
Air goes up without any help, what can you do (without fans) to help the passive flow upwards?
Additional green mod is now also made in my passive system: E8400 normally runs with 1,1125-1,225V. With the low clock setting (1,8GHz) I was able to undervolt it quite radically - now it's running with 0,9V and my load temperature is around 40. I must do some proper testing under similar conditions to see how much the undervolting really affected. The good thing is that UNDERVOLTING DOESN'T SLOW YOUR PC and doesn't cause any risks (well, a bluescreen if voltage is too low but that's not really a risk). Underclocking does slow the PC. My suggestion to everybody is this:
1. Put your normal maximum amount of programs to run at the same time
2. Check your processor usage %
3. Calculate your undercloking by that % ( mine: 60% x 3GHz = 1,8GHz). That's the biggest clock speed you ever need in a real use.
4. Especially if you have fast memory, you might loose some performance. Test the new clock setting once with your most calculating program/game.
5. When you find your minimal reasonable clock speed, start the undervolting (instructions are easy to goole) and find your minimum CPU voltage. Remember to make a full load test for long enough.
6. Check your temperatures at full load and see how many fans you can slow down / totally remove from your case. YOU MIGHT REALLY SURPRISE ! (i did)
7. Change your best fan into your PSU. Read instructions about getting rid of all electricity inside thwe PSU before you open it. Make sure it starts at low voltage and have enough airflow for your PSU. Air exhausting your PSU should not get over 40C (some might say 50C but the less is the better)
Air goes up without any help, what can you do (without fans) to help the passive flow upwards?
Additional green mod is now also made in my passive system: E8400 normally runs with 1,1125-1,225V. With the low clock setting (1,8GHz) I was able to undervolt it quite radically - now it's running with 0,9V and my load temperature is around 40. I must do some proper testing under similar conditions to see how much the undervolting really affected. The good thing is that UNDERVOLTING DOESN'T SLOW YOUR PC and doesn't cause any risks (well, a bluescreen if voltage is too low but that's not really a risk). Underclocking does slow the PC. My suggestion to everybody is this:
1. Put your normal maximum amount of programs to run at the same time
2. Check your processor usage %
3. Calculate your undercloking by that % ( mine: 60% x 3GHz = 1,8GHz). That's the biggest clock speed you ever need in a real use.
4. Especially if you have fast memory, you might loose some performance. Test the new clock setting once with your most calculating program/game.
5. When you find your minimal reasonable clock speed, start the undervolting (instructions are easy to goole) and find your minimum CPU voltage. Remember to make a full load test for long enough.
6. Check your temperatures at full load and see how many fans you can slow down / totally remove from your case. YOU MIGHT REALLY SURPRISE ! (i did)
7. Change your best fan into your PSU. Read instructions about getting rid of all electricity inside thwe PSU before you open it. Make sure it starts at low voltage and have enough airflow for your PSU. Air exhausting your PSU should not get over 40C (some might say 50C but the less is the better)
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 11:26 am
- Location: Sunny Swansea
-
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Fri Jan 08, 2010 10:30 pm
My guess to maximise case cooling and convection.
All intake vents at the bottom and all exhaust vents at the top. Heat sources towards the top and stacked horizontally. Streamlined internals to minimise the occurence of any hot air pockets. Raising the heat source(s) temperature will also aid convection.
All intake vents at the bottom and all exhaust vents at the top. Heat sources towards the top and stacked horizontally. Streamlined internals to minimise the occurence of any hot air pockets. Raising the heat source(s) temperature will also aid convection.
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
Big Pimp Daddy wrote:I'm guessing you either have a source of cold air (airbrick/vent) right next to the intake/bottom of your case and/or a heater above the case, boosting the convective effect.
even too close of the right answer nothing for intakes, something above, but not a heater (nothing that use energy)
as low as possible and as high as possible, yesPlanetOfTheApes, My guess to maximise case cooling and convection. wrote:
All intake vents at the bottom and all exhaust vents at the top.
rightHeat sources towards the top and stacked horizontally.
rightStreamlined internals to minimise the occurence of any hot air pockets.
rightRaising the heat source(s) temperature will also aid convection.
but still, these mods are already in both setups (before and after), so please guess again what i did between them.
-
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Fri Jan 08, 2010 10:30 pm
Are you reducing the temperature around the exhaust vent ?maalitehdas wrote:
even too close of the right answer nothing for intakes, something above, but not a heater (nothing that use energy)
Are you increasing the height/distance that the air inside the case needs to travel to exit outside the case ?
-
- Friend of SPCR
- Posts: 455
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2008 10:39 am
- Location: England
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
10 points to mr. EvilMr Evil wrote: In other words... a chimney!
And 9 points for everybody else who helped him to get it right
It's a 12cm wide, 1,2m long carton tube mounted right up from P182 top exhaust vent, working as a chimney (boosting natural airflow upwards).
I was really surprised of how much the temperatures fell, I recommend this solution for those who think sound level is more important than looks.
A few days later I blocked the back exhaust vent too, it helped the chimney to work even better.
-
- Posts: 62
- Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 12:23 pm
- Location: Massachusetts, USA
-
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 12:04 am
- Location: Finland
Photos coming up in few days, hope you have patient.
I'm working with more undervolting at the moment to see how green can I really get (and still run HD movies smoothly). Here's my situation at the moment, i don't really know if i can get any further without cutting some wires:
MB Abit ix38 quadGT
wattage (unknown, so let's use MB average) 34W
CPU Core2 duo E8400
clock 3,0GHz -> 1,8GHz
voltage 1,25V -> 0,8V
wattage (idle/load) 36W/65W -> 12W/17W
GPU geForce 210 GT
clock normal
voltage normal
wattage (idle/load) 6W/10W
MEMORY 2 x 1Gb DDR2 800
clock normal
voltage 1,95V -> 1,8V
wattage (both together) 0W/10W -> 0W/9W
HDD Seagate 7200rpm SATA
wattage (idle/load) 1W/10W
HDD WDC Green SATA
wattage (idle/load) 1W/6W
OPT drive
wattage (DVD-RW average) 1W/27W
USB cam
wattage (USB device average) 0W/2W
USB wireless keyboard+mouse
wattage (USB device average) 1W/2W
USB memory card reader
wattage (idle/load) 0W/9W
PSU Seasonic S12II 430W (scythe flex fan)
wattage (own consumption) unknown
total system power drawn (PSU efficiency calculated along)
IDLE 72W (56W / 77% efficiency)
HD playback 110W (90W / 82% efficiency)
LOAD 154W (126W / 82% efficiency)
Of cource the full load power is never needed, that would mean all the equipment running like hell at the same time. In HD playback I should calculate along my HDTV (Sony KDL40W4500) with 100W and surround system with about 40W. Watching one 2h movie seems to consume a total of 0,5kW of energy. A nice 7 cents a piece with current price/kW - quite nothing compared to what they take for movie rent.
But here's a more important comparison: what do i save with undervolting. Here are the numbers without undervolting:
IDLE 100W (80W / 80% efficiency)
HD playback 154W (126W / 82% efficiency)
LOAD 208W (175W / 84% efficiency)
Total savings: 2h HD playback 88W - 1,2 cents / movie
Total savings: IDLE 24/7 in 1 year - 245kWh = 34,35€
I'm working with more undervolting at the moment to see how green can I really get (and still run HD movies smoothly). Here's my situation at the moment, i don't really know if i can get any further without cutting some wires:
MB Abit ix38 quadGT
wattage (unknown, so let's use MB average) 34W
CPU Core2 duo E8400
clock 3,0GHz -> 1,8GHz
voltage 1,25V -> 0,8V
wattage (idle/load) 36W/65W -> 12W/17W
GPU geForce 210 GT
clock normal
voltage normal
wattage (idle/load) 6W/10W
MEMORY 2 x 1Gb DDR2 800
clock normal
voltage 1,95V -> 1,8V
wattage (both together) 0W/10W -> 0W/9W
HDD Seagate 7200rpm SATA
wattage (idle/load) 1W/10W
HDD WDC Green SATA
wattage (idle/load) 1W/6W
OPT drive
wattage (DVD-RW average) 1W/27W
USB cam
wattage (USB device average) 0W/2W
USB wireless keyboard+mouse
wattage (USB device average) 1W/2W
USB memory card reader
wattage (idle/load) 0W/9W
PSU Seasonic S12II 430W (scythe flex fan)
wattage (own consumption) unknown
total system power drawn (PSU efficiency calculated along)
IDLE 72W (56W / 77% efficiency)
HD playback 110W (90W / 82% efficiency)
LOAD 154W (126W / 82% efficiency)
Of cource the full load power is never needed, that would mean all the equipment running like hell at the same time. In HD playback I should calculate along my HDTV (Sony KDL40W4500) with 100W and surround system with about 40W. Watching one 2h movie seems to consume a total of 0,5kW of energy. A nice 7 cents a piece with current price/kW - quite nothing compared to what they take for movie rent.
But here's a more important comparison: what do i save with undervolting. Here are the numbers without undervolting:
IDLE 100W (80W / 80% efficiency)
HD playback 154W (126W / 82% efficiency)
LOAD 208W (175W / 84% efficiency)
Total savings: 2h HD playback 88W - 1,2 cents / movie
Total savings: IDLE 24/7 in 1 year - 245kWh = 34,35€