140 mm long PSU, non-modular, quiet?
Posted: Sun Oct 19, 2014 3:55 pm
(Jump to the bold text if you don't want to read it all.)
I'm interested in buying a Raijintek Metis case. Combined with a 140 mm long PSU it would be possible to use longer graphics cards than advertised (> 170 mm).
My current GTX 660 TI is actually 170 mm long, but I want to choose a PSU that fits with longer cards, just to be more future proof.
I'm using a 2600K with a Thermalright AXP-140 and a Arctic F12 PWM, 8 GB RAM, one SSD and one 2.5" HDD. I'd like to have some headroom for overclocking, nothing extreme tho.
I dont have an (apparent) silent environment, a low humming or whooshing PSU fan when not playing games is alright. My computer isn't silent anyway, but it can be made really quiet though. It will be placed under my desk.
I'm prepared to modify the case or the PSU if needed in the future (maybe also for GPU intake), but a 140 mm PSU is a must (like the Cooler Master V S in the picture).
The first choice would be a Seasonic G-360, but I'd like some extra power. Unfortunately, the bigger G's are 160 mm long, and the same goes for the P and X series
The S12G's actually looks like bigger versions of G-360, but they're too noisy. Antec Truepower Classic seems like a S12G to me, not sure tho.
Be quiets newer models are usually too long, and are made by Fortron, a step down in quality from Seasonic.
There are also some SFX models like the 600 W and more likely the upcoming 500 W models from Silverstone, but the build quality isn't that good and I prefer an ATX if possible.
There are some semi-modular PSUs that could fit, but the question is if they're qiuet enough. Cooler Master V550S is one of those, made by Enhance. The 750 W model got the highest build quality score at jonnyguru.com. The Yate Loon DB12BH-12 runs at 650 rpm up to 50 % load, which sounds pretty good if it wasn't for the fact that I have no idea what that fan sounds like. Yate Loon has a good reputation, but it's still a ball bearing fan at 650 rpm.
There are also some other similar semi modular PSUs from Corsair and others.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
In short, what I'm looking for: 140 mm long, non modular or semi modular, 5 year warranty, about 500 W, 24 + 8 pin ATX, 6 + 6 pin PCIE or better, high quality with decent capacitors (rated 105° C where expected), quiet up to 100 W at least
QUESTIONS:
1 - Any comments on the Cooler Master V550S, or the noise of the Yate Loon DB12BH-12 running at 650 rpm? Noise quality?
2 - Is there any Seasonic-made model I've missed? Maybe some of their own OEM models?
3 - Any other PSU I should look into? Are there semi passive PSU's I have missed? (Don't think it's the right thing for this case, it's better with a slow spinning fan.)
I'm interested in buying a Raijintek Metis case. Combined with a 140 mm long PSU it would be possible to use longer graphics cards than advertised (> 170 mm).
My current GTX 660 TI is actually 170 mm long, but I want to choose a PSU that fits with longer cards, just to be more future proof.
I'm using a 2600K with a Thermalright AXP-140 and a Arctic F12 PWM, 8 GB RAM, one SSD and one 2.5" HDD. I'd like to have some headroom for overclocking, nothing extreme tho.
I dont have an (apparent) silent environment, a low humming or whooshing PSU fan when not playing games is alright. My computer isn't silent anyway, but it can be made really quiet though. It will be placed under my desk.
I'm prepared to modify the case or the PSU if needed in the future (maybe also for GPU intake), but a 140 mm PSU is a must (like the Cooler Master V S in the picture).
The first choice would be a Seasonic G-360, but I'd like some extra power. Unfortunately, the bigger G's are 160 mm long, and the same goes for the P and X series
The S12G's actually looks like bigger versions of G-360, but they're too noisy. Antec Truepower Classic seems like a S12G to me, not sure tho.
Be quiets newer models are usually too long, and are made by Fortron, a step down in quality from Seasonic.
There are also some SFX models like the 600 W and more likely the upcoming 500 W models from Silverstone, but the build quality isn't that good and I prefer an ATX if possible.
There are some semi-modular PSUs that could fit, but the question is if they're qiuet enough. Cooler Master V550S is one of those, made by Enhance. The 750 W model got the highest build quality score at jonnyguru.com. The Yate Loon DB12BH-12 runs at 650 rpm up to 50 % load, which sounds pretty good if it wasn't for the fact that I have no idea what that fan sounds like. Yate Loon has a good reputation, but it's still a ball bearing fan at 650 rpm.
There are also some other similar semi modular PSUs from Corsair and others.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
In short, what I'm looking for: 140 mm long, non modular or semi modular, 5 year warranty, about 500 W, 24 + 8 pin ATX, 6 + 6 pin PCIE or better, high quality with decent capacitors (rated 105° C where expected), quiet up to 100 W at least
QUESTIONS:
1 - Any comments on the Cooler Master V550S, or the noise of the Yate Loon DB12BH-12 running at 650 rpm? Noise quality?
2 - Is there any Seasonic-made model I've missed? Maybe some of their own OEM models?
3 - Any other PSU I should look into? Are there semi passive PSU's I have missed? (Don't think it's the right thing for this case, it's better with a slow spinning fan.)