Which DVD Burner would you get?
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
-
- Posts: 47
- Joined: Thu May 06, 2004 4:32 pm
- Contact:
Which DVD Burner would you get?
I am probably going to get one of these:
NEC - $66
LG - $80
Plextor - $98.5
I want to know which one to get, so I want to know whether the quiet is worth getting a more expensive drive, so here's the best way to ask my question:
If you weren't going to burn any movies to be read in a DVD Player, which drive would you get?
Also, would you get one that I didn't list?
Thanks
NEC - $66
LG - $80
Plextor - $98.5
I want to know which one to get, so I want to know whether the quiet is worth getting a more expensive drive, so here's the best way to ask my question:
If you weren't going to burn any movies to be read in a DVD Player, which drive would you get?
Also, would you get one that I didn't list?
Thanks
I"d get the plextor. Its an excelent drive and worth the extra money. Go on to www.cdfreaks.com (http://club.cdfreaks.com/forumdisplay.php?f=43) and hear what people say about the burner. It has some nice features to it such as Quiet Mode and GigaBurn, both of which I use constantly.
-
- Patron of SPCR
- Posts: 258
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 9:54 am
- Location: FOLDING IN TORONTO, CANADA
- Contact:
I got a Plextor for Christmas from my brother. It runs reasonably loud and fast when it needs to, but if you're playing a CD or DVD is slows right down to near silent.
Haven't had any problems with it. Now just need to find a better backup solution that will allow me to burn the 4.7gig images instead of defaulting at 700meg
edit... I guess technically I could burn 6 images per DVD... worth a try I guess.
Haven't had any problems with it. Now just need to find a better backup solution that will allow me to burn the 4.7gig images instead of defaulting at 700meg
edit... I guess technically I could burn 6 images per DVD... worth a try I guess.
-
- Patron of SPCR
- Posts: 258
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 9:54 am
- Location: FOLDING IN TORONTO, CANADA
- Contact:
I'm trying out TrueImage... seems to work really well so far, although I'm just backing up to a spare HD at the moment. Playing around with the DVD/RW functionality now. If all works as it should, I'll be laughing.Nefarious wrote:wooglin,
What program are you using? I use Acronis True Image, and seems to work well.
From what I've seen, does TrueImage allow image sizes (splits) larger than 700 meg? Will it write direct to a DVD? Is my idea of writing 6 CD images to a DVD workable?
Sorry for threadjacking.
Just bought an LG GSA 4163B in black for $AU108. cheap as chips!
I've only had it a week, and haven't burnt anything with it yet, but backing-up DVDs at full-speed is reasonably quiet. Not SILENT quiet, but not too bad, considering.
The GSA 4163 can burn DVD+/-RW, Dual Layer, and burn DVDRAM discs.
There's a few reviews around the place.
I've only had it a week, and haven't burnt anything with it yet, but backing-up DVDs at full-speed is reasonably quiet. Not SILENT quiet, but not too bad, considering.
The GSA 4163 can burn DVD+/-RW, Dual Layer, and burn DVDRAM discs.
There's a few reviews around the place.
-
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 11:09 pm
- Location: ID
I just ordered the PLextor PX-716SA SATA DVD drive. Then I started looking at what features it has. It has a SilentMode utlility which allows you to control read/write speeds, spin-up/down rates, and even tray open/close speeds. ALl to make it more quiet. The only reason I can see to have a quiet optical drive, would be in a HTPC in a small living room or bedroom where you could hear the drive spinning over a movie. In almost any other circumstance, you really dont need it to be quiet. When you are burning or copying a CD or DVD, its gonna be loud no matter what you do. But I would go with a Plextor. The 712 also has this feature I believe. Good luck!
Are all these fancy features supported only in MS OSes? Or is there also a support for Linux & BSDs?Nefarious wrote:I"d get the plextor. Its an excelent drive and worth the extra money. Go on to www.cdfreaks.com (http://club.cdfreaks.com/forumdisplay.php?f=43) and hear what people say about the burner. It has some nice features to it such as Quiet Mode and GigaBurn, both of which I use constantly.
Thanks,
Karel
-
- Posts: 380
- Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2004 12:44 pm
- Location: UK
I got LG GSA 4163B and very impressed with it.
It is not quet (actually, are there any quiet high speed optical drives?), but extremely smooooth drive: it smoothly spins up, does the job and spins down. For the 1st time I feel there is no need to artificially slow down the drive (as I had to do with Plextor PX-708A, which was quieter then the newer drives from Plextor)
It is not quet (actually, are there any quiet high speed optical drives?), but extremely smooooth drive: it smoothly spins up, does the job and spins down. For the 1st time I feel there is no need to artificially slow down the drive (as I had to do with Plextor PX-708A, which was quieter then the newer drives from Plextor)
Got the Plextor PX-716A myself. Not a totally quiet drive, seeing what we are accostomed (sp?) here but for reliability it CANNOT be beat. I have burned about 150 dvds and only one coaster. I messed up.
As far as movie playing goes for a HTPC, I do not see a problem at al. Quiet in that respect. Seems to be nearly silent for first 90-120secs of a 8x burn and then ramps up to fairly loud by end of the burn.
As far as movie playing goes for a HTPC, I do not see a problem at al. Quiet in that respect. Seems to be nearly silent for first 90-120secs of a 8x burn and then ramps up to fairly loud by end of the burn.
As mentioned in a previous post, the Plextor has software provided to allow it run in quiet mode, if you can settle for a little less speed.munichkid wrote:Got the Plextor PX-716A myself. Not a totally quiet drive, seeing what we are accostomed (sp?) here but for reliability it CANNOT be beat.
Last edited by m0002a on Tue Mar 22, 2005 9:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 171
- Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2004 7:11 am
- Location: manahttan beach, ca
- Contact:
Though I'm a fan of Plextor (their PlexTools is a very complete package), for a Quiet DVD burner, I'd pay attention to this post by a trusted staff member.
Plextor has a reputation (well deserved) for having better compatibility than just about any other drive. Not all media brands are compatible with all drives, and not all drives can correctly interpret all the formats (especially if you are trying to rip an existing music CD).
If you slow the Plextor down to BenQ speeds, it is quiet. However I suspect that the BenQ is priced lower than the Plextor, since most of their products are about the lowest price one can find in their category.
The Plextor PX-716A/SW has a $30 mail-in-rebate offer until 31 March 2005, making the net price about $107.00 at NewEgg.
If you slow the Plextor down to BenQ speeds, it is quiet. However I suspect that the BenQ is priced lower than the Plextor, since most of their products are about the lowest price one can find in their category.
The Plextor PX-716A/SW has a $30 mail-in-rebate offer until 31 March 2005, making the net price about $107.00 at NewEgg.
Having tried just about every single 16x burner model and also read anechoic chamber dBA measurements done by c't magazine, I'd select either of the two (for true hc spcr people):
- Pioneer DVR-A09XLA (can be stepped down to much quieter mode with QuietDrive utility)
- Plextor PX-716A (can be stepped down in speed to much quieter mode with Plextools Pro)
Granted, neither is the best dvd-burner in terms of media support or burn quality, but they are both good.
Remember, none of the 16x writers is anywhere near quiet at normal speeds (i.e. not slowed down with a utility).
BTC's drive comes the closest at stock speeds, but it's a horrendous writer and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
I'm still using both myself (along with BenQ, LiteOn, AOpen, Optorite, etc. ad nauseaum).
I'd utterly and completely stay away from LiteOns. They are very noisy.
regards,
halcyon
PS If you want to gamble and try Nec ND-3540A with one of the speed down utilities (CD Bremse, Nero Drive speed - which may or may not work - no guarantees), then you could get a very wide media support + very good burn quality AND a semi-quiet drive (the same goes for BenQ DW1620).
- Pioneer DVR-A09XLA (can be stepped down to much quieter mode with QuietDrive utility)
- Plextor PX-716A (can be stepped down in speed to much quieter mode with Plextools Pro)
Granted, neither is the best dvd-burner in terms of media support or burn quality, but they are both good.
Remember, none of the 16x writers is anywhere near quiet at normal speeds (i.e. not slowed down with a utility).
BTC's drive comes the closest at stock speeds, but it's a horrendous writer and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
I'm still using both myself (along with BenQ, LiteOn, AOpen, Optorite, etc. ad nauseaum).
I'd utterly and completely stay away from LiteOns. They are very noisy.
regards,
halcyon
PS If you want to gamble and try Nec ND-3540A with one of the speed down utilities (CD Bremse, Nero Drive speed - which may or may not work - no guarantees), then you could get a very wide media support + very good burn quality AND a semi-quiet drive (the same goes for BenQ DW1620).
Perhaps most worryingly about the pioneers is their data corruption bug (when the drive experiences a read error, rather than reporting that, it substitutes random data). Which is a pity, because it produces very low error rates on CDs. I couldn't in all conscience suggest getting a pioneer since they've been unwilling to sort it out (Just for the record there are some cheap non pioneer drives that crash rather than substituting random data when they get a read error. More annoying, but better behaviour).
I would suggest talking to http://www.infinadyne.com/ as they're the ones who discovered this/worked out what was causing the problems. After it was explained; the wierd behaviour of the drive became clear. I don't have all the information about it; but strongly suspect that disc structure is important in reproducing this bug.
If you're ever going to do audio extraction, buy a Plextor and only a Plextor. There once was this site from 'R3mix' full of measurements and for reliability and error-correction the Plextor drives always won.
It's the only brand that will ever get into my PC.
(I recently ordered a PX-716 for my new system, arriving any day now)
Peter
It's the only brand that will ever get into my PC.
(I recently ordered a PX-716 for my new system, arriving any day now)
Peter
I use a Plextor drive myself, a PX-712. This drive is pretty good and very reliable... When I first installed it, it was a bit too loud but with Plextools Professional, I was able to lower the drive speed and also the tray speed (loading/eject)... The drive came with EasyCD Creator 6 which I really don't like... I installed Nero 6 instead which is far better!
I removed Plextools at startup because for strange reasons, it took 100% CPU resources! Since the changes made with Plextools are directly written to the drive, you don't need Plextools in the background. Writing settings to the drive instead of using a TSR is a very good thing!The silentmode settings of the drive will remain when they are "saved to the drive" and this even when PlexTools Professional is not active or installed.
Plextools Professional came with my Plextor... The bundled version was very buggy, so I downloaded the latest version on Plextor's website and installed it... I mainly use Plextools to control the drive speed...Wraith wrote:Am I right to assume that Plextools Professional either comes with the drive or is downloadable for free from their website?